World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
DSA’s quest to expand into Staten Island crashes and burns at lefty convention
Staten Island members of the Democratic Socialists of America will remain in the group’s South Brooklyn branch after delegates declined to advance a proposal for an independent borough branch. The outcome highlights the difficulty of expanding the organisation in a borough where Republicans continue to hold elected offices.
At the group’s biennial convention, 203 of 436 delegates supported putting the proposal on the agenda, falling short of a majority. Introduced by Staten Island activist and delegate Samuel Rozenfeld, the plan cited the borough’s high per-capita number of government union members as an organising opportunity. However, Republicans retained Staten Island’s three state Assembly seats, two state Senate seats and congressional seat, and gained a state judgeship; some local union members work in uniformed services and tend to vote conservatively or moderately.
In short
- DSA delegates did not advance a proposal for a Staten Island branch.
- Staten Island members will stay in the South Brooklyn branch.
- The proposal received 203 of 436 delegate votes.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A dedicated Staten Island branch could build a stronger local presence by organising around the borough’s substantial government-union membership and developing campaigns suited to local concerns. Supporters could argue that a separate structure would give members more ownership and visibility, helping the DSA reach residents who may not identify with the politics or priorities of a branch based elsewhere.
The case against
Keeping Staten Island in the South Brooklyn branch could make better use of the organisation’s limited people and resources, especially where the DSA has not yet built a large local base. Opponents could argue that a new branch would add structure before there is enough support to sustain it, and that the borough’s mixed or conservative voting patterns call for careful local organising rather than assuming union membership will translate into socialist support.
Explained simply
The Democratic Socialists of America (DSA) is a membership organisation that supports left-wing politics and campaigns for policies such as stronger public services and workers’ rights. Its local members are organised into branches, which coordinate activity in different parts of a city.
Staten Island is one of New York City’s five boroughs, but its elected representatives have largely been Republicans. DSA members there are currently part of the group’s South Brooklyn branch; an independent branch would give them a separate local structure.
The proposal pointed to the borough’s many government-union members as a possible base for organising. But union members do not all share the same politics, and some uniformed-service workers lean more conservative or moderate, making it harder for the DSA to build support locally.