Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Eli Roth’s Sugary Carnage Doesn’t Add Up to Much in ‘Ice Cream Man’ | Review
Collider's review finds that Eli Roth's new horror-comedy "Ice Cream Man" delivers impressive practical gore effects but ultimately fails to sustain its premise beyond its shock value. The film follows a sinister ice cream truck vendor whose treats turn children in an idyllic small town into violent monsters, tapping into the recent resurgence of splatter-focused horror popularised by franchises like Terrifier, but the review argues that once the novelty of the kills wears off, there is little substance left to hold the film together.
The story centres on a 1950s-style town where a silent, mustachioed Ice Cream Man (Ari Millen) secretly turns local children into zombie-like killers at night, leaving a handful of uninfected kids and teenagers, including siblings Jared (Charlie Zeltzer) and Lizzie (Sarah Abbott), to fight back. Director Roth, known for Cabin Fever, Hostel and Thanksgiving, also appears in a small role. The reviewer praises the effects work, singling out a scene involving an ice cream scoop and a victim's brain as a standout, but concludes that the relentless gore becomes numbing and exposes a thin plot once the shock factor fades.
In short
- Eli Roth's "Ice Cream Man" horror comedy reviewed by Collider
- Praised for gory practical effects, criticised for thin plot
- Excessive violence dulls impact, leaving little else to sustain the film
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Horror films should ultimately offer something beyond visual shock to remain genuinely engaging. Once the novelty of gore effects fades, audiences are left with thin characterisation and plot that fail to sustain interest, as the relentless spectacle of gore becomes numbing rather than impactful. Effective splatter horror demonstrates how visceral imagery serves a larger purpose; when shock becomes the sole purpose, the film's foundation crumbles.
The case against
Splatter horror-comedies operate within valid artistic conventions where practical effects mastery and visceral thrills are themselves the primary content, not mere ornamentation for plot. The artistry of creating memorable, creative kills and the entertainment value of sustained absurdist gore are legitimate achievements in their own right. Judging these films by conventional narrative standards misses their intent; the pleasure comes from committed genre craftsmanship and the audience's embrace of spectacle as the main event.
Explained simply
Eli Roth is a film-maker known for horror films such as Cabin Fever, Hostel and Thanksgiving. His new film, Ice Cream Man, is set in a town styled after 1950s America, where a quiet ice cream seller’s treats turn children into violent, zombie-like creatures.
A small group of children and teenagers, including siblings Jared and Lizzie, try to survive and fight back. The film belongs to a current wave of horror that puts graphic effects and shocking scenes at the centre of the experience, a style also associated with the Terrifier films.
The review praises Ice Cream Man’s practical gore effects but says the violence grows repetitive and the story offers little to sustain interest. That tension matters because the film’s appeal depends on whether its shock and spectacle are enough to carry the premise.