World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Erewhon’s absurd Thanksgiving dinner takeout for $749 doesn’t even include cranberry sauce
Erewhon, the luxury California grocer, is selling a Thanksgiving takeout meal for $749, designed to serve eight to ten people. It includes a cooked turkey, sides, gravy and pumpkin pie, but no cranberry sauce, which must be bought separately.
A smaller meal for four to six costs $439, while a vegan option for the same number costs $340. The article contrasts those prices with Aldi’s $39 meal for ten and notes that hosting costs are rising: a survey found hosts expect to spend an average of $427 this year, up 3%, while grocery prices rose 0.4% in October.
In short
- Erewhon’s Thanksgiving feast costs $749 for eight to ten people.
- Cranberry sauce is not included.
- Aldi advertises a $39 meal for ten.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Erewhon’s meal may be a convenient, carefully prepared option for people who value saving time, premium ingredients and a distinctive holiday experience. Its price reflects a luxury market serving customers willing and able to pay more, while the smaller and vegan packages offer alternatives for different households.
The case against
At $749 for eight to ten people, the meal costs far more than many families can reasonably justify, especially as hosting expenses and grocery prices rise. The missing cranberry sauce may reinforce the impression that the package offers poor value, and its luxury pricing highlights how differently households experience the cost of a holiday meal.
Explained simply
Thanksgiving is a major US holiday, held on the fourth Thursday in November, when families and friends often gather for a meal. Roast turkey, side dishes and pumpkin pie are common foods, and cranberry sauce is a familiar accompaniment.
Erewhon is a high-end grocery chain based in California, known for premium food and prepared meals. Its holiday takeout is aimed at people who want a ready-made feast; other retailers, including discount supermarket Aldi, sell Thanksgiving meals at lower prices.
The meal’s price sits within a wider concern about the cost of hosting. Food prices and household budgets affect how much people spend on holiday gatherings.