Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Ex-SLIPKNOT Drummer JAY WEINBERG Is Not Interested In Using A.I. To Create Music: ‘I Can’t Relate To Why Anybody Would Want To Shortchange The Artistic Experience’
Former SLIPKNOT drummer Jay Weinberg said he avoids using artificial intelligence to create music, arguing that it cuts out the human experience that gives art meaning. Speaking at the UK Drum Show in Liverpool, he said he values music that reflects the creator’s emotions and struggles, and that he wants to make work that moves him.
Weinberg cited filmmaker Guillermo del Toro’s view that a robot cannot experience love, loss or pain. He said he is less interested in technically perfect work than in authentic expression. His career spans SLIPKNOT, Bruce Springsteen’s E Street Band and other groups; he has received four Grammy nominations and played on three Billboard chart-topping records.
In short
- Weinberg rejects AI-generated music as lacking human experience.
- He values authentic expression over technical perfection.
- His career includes four Grammy nominations and three chart-topping records.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Weinberg’s position is that music matters partly because it carries a person’s emotions, choices and lived experience; using AI to generate it can make the result feel detached from those sources of meaning. Prioritising authentic expression over technical perfection also protects the role of human creativity and struggle in making art.
The case against
AI can be viewed as another instrument or creative aid, rather than a substitute for human experience: people still choose what to make, shape the output and give it meaning. Used thoughtfully, it may help artists experiment or realise ideas they could not otherwise produce, while broadening access to music-making.
Explained simply
Artificial intelligence, or A.I., refers to computer systems that can generate things such as music from prompts and examples. Its use in creative work has prompted debate about whether computer-generated results can convey the feelings and experiences associated with human-made art.
Jay Weinberg is an American drummer who has played with Slipknot, Bruce Springsteen’s E Street Band and other groups. His comments reflect a wider discussion among musicians and audiences about the role of technology in making music and what listeners value in a performance.
AI Entertainment Music Technology UK World