Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
EXCLUSIVE: Big Banks Weaponized Climate To Punish Customers, Watchdog Says
Consumers’ Research is asking the US Office of the Comptroller of the Currency to investigate climate-related policies at JPMorgan, Citi, Bank of America and Morgan Stanley. The watchdog argues that net-zero commitments could restrict access to finance for some customers and expose banks and consumers to greater risks.
In a letter, executive director Will Hild says climate targets may steer lending towards riskier start-ups, pressure higher-emitting businesses to change or lose financing, and contribute to higher energy costs. He cites Silicon Valley Bank’s failure as a warning about risk and claims JPMorgan, Bank of America and Morgan Stanley helped Chinese battery maker CATL raise billions. The OCC issued a report in October on politically motivated debanking at the same banks; the claims in the new letter are arguments by Consumers’ Research.
In short
- Consumers’ Research seeks an OCC investigation into four banks’ climate policies.
- The group says climate targets could affect lending and customer access to finance.
- The OCC has previously reported politically motivated debanking at these banks.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A bank’s climate commitments can affect which businesses it finances, potentially limiting credit for energy-intensive firms even when they meet ordinary lending criteria. The OCC should examine whether such policies create undue customer harm or financial risk, and whether they are applied transparently and consistently; scrutiny is especially reasonable given the regulator’s recent attention to debanking.
The case against
Banks can reasonably take climate risks into account because exposure to changing policy, technology and extreme weather may affect borrowers’ ability to repay and the banks’ own stability. Net-zero targets need not mean denying finance to customers, and claims that they steer lending towards riskier firms or raise energy costs require evidence; a watchdog’s allegations and comparisons with unrelated bank failures do not by themselves establish that climate policies caused harm.