Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
First Clip From HBO’s Harry Potter Series Soundtrack Isn’t Going Down Well With Fans
A short clip from HBO’s upcoming Harry Potter series has prompted criticism of Hans Zimmer’s score, with fans comparing the music unfavourably to John Williams’ well-known film compositions. The reaction matters because Zimmer’s work is the first music released from the series, leading some listeners to judge the wider soundtrack from a brief sample.
The music accompanies a start-of-term banquet scene and is intended as light background music, rather than the series’ main theme. Zimmer is composing the score with Kara Talve and Anže Rozman of Bleeding Fingers Music; HBO is due to premiere the first episode on 25 December, with further episodes continuing into early 2027.
In short
- Fans have criticised the first released sample of Zimmer’s Harry Potter score.
- The clip features light background music, not the main theme.
- HBO’s series is scheduled to begin on 25 December.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The clip is only a brief piece of light banquet music, not the series’ main theme, so it may not represent the score as a whole. A new adaptation can benefit from its own musical identity, and Zimmer and his collaborators deserve to be heard across more than a short sample before their work is judged.
The case against
Williams’ music is closely associated with the Harry Potter films, so listeners may reasonably expect a new screen adaptation to retain some of its distinctive atmosphere. As the first music released from the series, the clip invites scrutiny; if it feels less memorable or fitting to fans, that may raise a fair question about whether the new score captures what they value in the original.