Sport news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Flying sneaker gets Liberty star ejected in bizarre finish that leaves WNBA fans in disbelief
A New York Liberty player, Betnijah Laney-Hamilton, was ejected late in a 93-91 loss to the Toronto Tempo after a shoe she threw towards team-mate Jonquel Jones accidentally struck Toronto's Marina Mabrey. The incident happened during the Liberty’s comeback attempt and became a decisive moment because officials called a technical foul and removed Laney-Hamilton from the game. It mattered because the unusual decision immediately affected the closing stages of a tight WNBA contest and prompted strong reactions from players, coaches and fans.
According to the report, New York entered the fourth quarter 16 points behind before rallying, but the incident halted that momentum. Laney-Hamilton had already received a Flagrant 1 earlier in the game, which added to the scrutiny when the stray trainer hit Mabrey. Laney-Hamilton said she was only trying to return Jones’s shoe and did not mean to hit anyone, while Mabrey suggested she believed it was accidental even as she benefited from the free throw. Liberty acting head coach Chris DeMarco criticised the officiating, calling the decision game-altering and saying he had never seen anything like it.
In short
- Flying shoe led to late Liberty ejection
- Toronto beat New York 93-91
- Players saw it as accidental, coach blasted officials
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The rules must be enforced consistently to protect player safety, and a shoe striking an opponent—regardless of stated intent—breaches fundamental conduct standards. Laney-Hamilton had already received a Flagrant 1 earlier in the game, indicating a pattern of physical play requiring stricter enforcement by that stage. Officials cannot afford to distinguish between intentional and accidental projectiles mid-game, as doing so would invite inconsistency and set a problematic precedent that contact is permissible if apologised for afterwards. The technical foul and ejection served necessary deterrence to maintain game integrity.
The case against
The ejection was manifestly disproportionate punishment for an accidental incident that the affected player herself acknowledged as unintentional. Laney-Hamilton was attempting to return a teammate's shoe, not throwing it in anger or as a weapon, and both the immediate context and subsequent statements made this clear. An ejection is an extreme sanction reserved for intentional misconduct or dangerous behaviour, not for unfortunate accidents; compounding this with a prior Flagrant 1 turns a mishap into a game-deciding penalty that fundamentally altered the match during a crucial comeback. Rules must meaningfully distinguish between intentional acts and genuine accidents, lest enforcement become capricious rather than reasoned.
Explained simply
During a Women's National Basketball Association match between New York Liberty and Toronto Tempo, a trainer thrown by Liberty player Betnijah Laney-Hamilton struck Toronto's Marina Mabrey. Laney-Hamilton had been attempting to return the shoe to teammate Jonquel Jones. Officials issued a technical foul and ejected her from the match.
The Liberty had been attempting a comeback after falling 16 points behind in the final quarter. The incident occurred late in the competitive match, with the Liberty ultimately losing 93-91 to Toronto. The technical foul decision awarded Toronto a free throw at a crucial stage.
Laney-Hamilton stated that the contact was unintentional and she was only trying to return her teammate's shoe. Mabrey suggested she believed the incident was accidental. Laney-Hamilton had already received a Flagrant 1 foul earlier in the match, which added to controversy over the ejection decision.
Basketball Celebrity Entertainment Offbeat Sport Weird & Viral World