World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Texas court blocks 76-year-old sex offender from taking custody of surrogate-born son
A 76-year-old man with convictions for abusing boys arranged for a surrogate to have a child he intended to raise as a single father, a Texas court heard. Social workers intervened shortly before the baby’s birth after his history came to light, and he was prevented from taking custody.
Court records say Sanford Kaplan agreed in February 2025 to pay the Texas woman about $50,000 to carry a boy conceived with his sperm and a donor egg. Kaplan pleaded no contest in 2009 to seven counts of child abuse and one of false imprisonment after abusing boys aged 10 to 15; he served seven years of a 24-year sentence and completed parole in 2021. The article says a home safety study was bypassed after a joint request, and an affidavit cited Kaplan’s statement that there may have been 17 or 18 victims.
In short
- A Texas court heard Kaplan arranged a surrogacy while concealing his convictions.
- Social workers stopped him taking custody of the baby.
- An affidavit cited his estimate of 17 or 18 victims.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The strongest case for allowing Kaplan to seek custody is that past convictions, however serious, should not automatically settle a person’s present parental fitness; decisions should rest on an individual assessment of current risk and the child’s welfare. A fair process can weigh his sentence, parole and any evidence of rehabilitation while considering whether safeguards and supervision could protect the child.
The case against
The strongest case for blocking custody is that the offences involved repeated abuse of boys, and the reported possibility of many victims raises grave concerns about the risk to a child in his care. Given the child’s vulnerability and the difficulty of undoing harm, a court could reasonably give priority to precaution and stable protection, particularly where the usual home safety study was bypassed.
Explained simply
Surrogacy is an arrangement in which a woman carries a pregnancy for someone who intends to become the child’s parent. Here, court records say Sanford Kaplan arranged for a Texas woman to carry a boy conceived using his sperm and an egg from a donor.
Kaplan had previously pleaded no contest to offences involving the abuse and imprisonment of boys, and served a prison sentence before completing parole in 2021. The case raises questions about how child welfare authorities assess a prospective parent’s history and what safeguards apply in surrogacy arrangements.
The central concern is the child’s safety and who can take legal responsibility for him. Courts and social workers may consider a person’s past conduct when deciding whether a proposed care arrangement is suitable.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “Former child sex offender, 76, who suspended boys from rafters of his home paid surrogate to have his baby so he could raise infant as single dad”.