World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Colorado watchdog alleges firms breach law by withholding drilling chemicals
A FracTracker Alliance analysis alleges that fossil-fuel operators are breaching Colorado law by failing to disclose chemicals used in drilling. The dispute matters because regulators have excluded drilling compounds from disclosure requirements, while the non-profit says the 2022 law covers all chemicals used underground in oil and gas wells.
Operators and suppliers must report downhole chemical ingredients to the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission within 150 days, after which the agency must publish them. FracTracker says at least five chemicals reported for fracking are prohibited in Colorado and at least three others raise serious safety concerns; about 43,000 people live within a mile of the state’s wells. The commission says it is applying current rules while working with stakeholders to clarify the requirements.
In short
- FracTracker alleges Colorado operators are not disclosing drilling chemicals.
- Regulators say they are applying current rules and clarifying the requirements.
- About 43,000 people live within a mile of Colorado wells.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The law’s broad wording can reasonably be read to cover every chemical used underground in an oil and gas well, including drilling compounds. Disclosure would let regulators and nearby residents assess potential risks, and FracTracker’s findings suggest that withholding ingredients may obscure chemicals that are prohibited or raise safety concerns.
The case against
Operators and suppliers can reasonably rely on the commission’s current rules, which exclude drilling compounds, until the requirements are clarified; compliance should be judged against clear, consistently applied guidance. They may also argue that ingredient reporting should distinguish chemicals used in different stages of well operations, so regulators can focus disclosure on relevant risks while avoiding unnecessary burdens or confusion.
Explained simply
Colorado regulates oil and gas drilling through the Colorado Energy and Carbon Management Commission. A 2022 law requires operators and suppliers to report the ingredients of chemicals used underground in wells, with reports due within 150 days and the information then published by the commission.
The disagreement is over which chemicals the law covers: the commission’s rules exclude some drilling compounds, while FracTracker Alliance says the law applies to all chemicals used underground. FracTracker is a non-profit that analyses oil and gas activity and says disclosure matters for assessing potential risks to people living near wells and to the environment.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “Fossil-fuel industry accused of violating Colorado law over not disclosing drilling chemicals”.