World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Furious Liberal Andrew Hastie declares war on Pauline Hanson as he claims he was called a traitor: ‘Lying cowards’
Liberal frontbencher Andrew Hastie has accused One Nation leader Pauline Hanson and Nationals figure Barnaby Joyce of being "lying cowards" after they denied labelling him a traitor, escalating a public dispute rooted in his testimony at the Ben Roberts-Smith defamation trial. The row matters because it pits a sitting government frontbencher and former SAS officer against a minor party targeting his own electorate, and touches on sensitive questions about veterans' conduct and the treatment of war crimes allegations in Australian politics.
Speaking in Canberra, Hastie cited a July 23 episode of Hanson's animated series "Please Explain", which he says calls him a traitor eight times over his court testimony and his support for hate speech legislation. He demanded Hanson and Joyce either "own" the cartoon and justify the claim or delete it, arguing the slur also implicated the 26 other combat veterans who gave evidence under oath, and noted that One Nation is targeting his seat of Canning at the next election.
In short
- Hastie accuses Hanson and Joyce of denying calling him a traitor
- Dispute stems from his Ben Roberts-Smith trial testimony
- One Nation is targeting Hastie's seat of Canning next election
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Hastie’s case is that calling him a traitor over sworn testimony unfairly attacks his integrity and risks discrediting other veterans who gave evidence. He can reasonably expect Hanson and Joyce to take responsibility for material published by their political movement, explain the accusation or remove it, particularly as One Nation is contesting his seat.
The case against
Hanson and Joyce may argue that political cartoons and sharp criticism are legitimate forms of political speech, especially when directed at a public figure whose testimony and policy positions are matters of public debate. They may also maintain that they should not be held responsible for a characterisation they deny making, and that demanding deletion before their responsibility is established would be unfair.
Explained simply
Andrew Hastie is a Liberal Party MP for Canning in Western Australia and a former Australian Army officer who served with the Special Air Service Regiment. Pauline Hanson leads One Nation, a smaller political party, and Barnaby Joyce is a former Nationals leader.
Hastie gave evidence in a defamation case brought by former soldier Ben Roberts-Smith against several newspapers over reports alleging war crimes in Afghanistan; Roberts-Smith has denied the allegations. The case drew evidence from serving and former military personnel, making the conduct of Australian forces and how allegations are handled matters of public debate.
The dispute also comes as One Nation seeks support in Hastie’s electorate. It connects claims made in political media with the testimony of veterans in court, and with wider debate about how politicians discuss military service and allegations of wrongdoing.