Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
GameStop chief criticises digital-only games as GTA 6 drops discs
Developing story first seen 3 hours ago
New coverage adds that the debate over digital game ownership has reached the courts: Sony has argued that digital games cannot be owned, while some in the crypto industry propose blockchain-based ownership as a solution. The issue has gained attention as GameStop chief executive Ryan Cohen criticises publishers for dropping physical discs, saying digital-only games prevent buyers from reselling, trading or lending them.
Take-Two Interactive is releasing Grand Theft Auto 6, priced at $80, as a download, with shops selling boxes containing download codes. Pre-owned and refurbished products made up 22% of GameStop’s sales, about $171 million, in the quarter ending 1 August, down 32% year on year. Wider efforts include a proposed US law requiring ongoing access to purchased games and a European citizens’ initiative that collected 1.3 million signatures calling for games to remain playable after support ends.
- Sources
- 4
- Outlets
- 4
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Sony says digital games cannot be owned.
- GTA 6 is an $80 download-only release.
- GameStop says pre-owned sales fell 32% year on year.
How this story developed
- 8 minutes ago Fresh coverage returned to the question of whether buyers own digital games, repeating Sony’s court position and Cohen’s criticism as the US considered a law requiring continued access to purchased titles.
- 21 minutes ago The ownership dispute reached the courts, where Sony argued that digital games cannot be owned, while a European citizens’ initiative gathered 1.3 million signatures calling for games to remain playable after support ends.
- 1 hour ago GameStop chief executive Ryan Cohen criticised publishers for abandoning physical discs as Grand Theft Auto 6 was set to sell for $80 as a digital download, putting pressure on the retailer’s second-hand business and prompting wider efforts to preserve access to games.
- Eurogamer GameStop CEO slams 'code-in-a-box' games in the wake of GTA 6's discless release
- GamesRadar+ As digital-only GTA 6 smashes records, GameStop CEO says move from physical copies "hurt consumers"
- Decrypt GameStop chief criticises digital-only games as GTA 6 drops discs
- IGN As GTA 6 Skips Discs, GameStop CEO Says Digital-Only 'Has Hurt Consumers' and Retailers
Full account
GameStop chief executive Ryan Cohen has criticised the games industry’s shift towards digital releases, saying it limits what customers can do with games they have paid for and weakens retailers that depend on trade-ins. In an interview with Bloomberg, he argued that buyers should be able to resell, exchange or lend a game. He said the move to digital had harmed both consumers and GameStop.
The debate has sharpened around Grand Theft Auto 6, which is being sold as a digital download rather than on a game disc. Retailers may offer boxed versions, but these contain download codes. Cohen described the format as “a code in a box” and said GameStop was selling a lot of them. His remarks address a commercial shift affecting the retailer: Bloomberg reported that pre-owned and refurbished products accounted for 22 per cent of GameStop sales in the quarter ending 1 August, a figure down 32 per cent on a year earlier.
Cohen said he had spoken with publishers about trade-ins. He argued that used games compete with new sales and that publishers therefore have an incentive to restrict them. The reports describe his comments as criticism of the broader move away from discs, though the second and third accounts connect them particularly closely to GTA 6. Neither attributes to Cohen a direct criticism of the game’s publisher in the Bloomberg interview; the first report says Take-Two Interactive declined to comment.
The issue extends beyond one release. Sony has said it will stop producing discs for new PlayStation games from January 2028, according to the reports. Meanwhile, proposals to protect access to purchased games have gained attention: US representative Ritchie Torres is backing legislation called the Power to the Players Act, and the European Stop Killing Games campaign has collected 1.3 million signatures for an initiative seeking to keep games playable after official support ends. These efforts reflect a wider dispute over whether digital purchases give players lasting control of the games they buy.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
The Bloomberg-based first report adds policy and ownership context, including the proposed US legislation, the European citizens’ initiative and court arguments over whether digital games can be owned. The other two focus more on the trade-in market and the immediate significance of GTA 6.
The second report adds that codes may remain region-locked on PS5 and includes sales estimates, workplace concerns and tribunal details about Rockstar; those points are not covered by the other reports. The third includes no comparable policy or legal detail and frames the issue more around collectors and player control.
The first says Take-Two is releasing the $80 game as a download and that retailers sell boxes containing codes. The second and third likewise describe code-in-a-box editions, while the third gives less detail on the retail arrangement.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Physical releases give players a tangible product they can resell, trade or lend, preserving choice and some value after purchase. They can also offer a measure of access if a publisher later withdraws a game or its online support, so moving to downloads may leave consumers more dependent on publishers’ decisions.
The case against
Digital releases can be more convenient, avoid the costs and materials involved in manufacturing and shipping discs, and make games easier to buy and access without visiting a shop. Publishers may also favour digital distribution because it gives them more control over sales and support; concerns about access can be addressed through clear policies or laws without requiring every game to have a disc.
Explained simply
Physical games are bought on discs or cartridges, while digital games are downloaded through an online shop and tied to an account. A physical copy can usually be lent, resold or traded in; digital copies are generally governed by the platform’s terms and may not be transferable.
GameStop is a US retailer that sells new and second-hand games, so trade-ins help support part of its business. Take-Two Interactive makes the Grand Theft Auto series, while Sony makes PlayStation consoles and games. The move towards downloads also raises questions about whether buyers can keep accessing games if a publisher or online service stops supporting them.
Coverage · 4 sources
- DecryptGameStop chief criticises digital-only games as GTA 6 drops discs
- EurogamerGameStop CEO slams 'code-in-a-box' games in the wake of GTA 6's discless release
- GamesRadar+As digital-only GTA 6 smashes records, GameStop CEO says move from physical copies "hurt consumers"
- IGNAs GTA 6 Skips Discs, GameStop CEO Says Digital-Only 'Has Hurt Consumers' and Retailers
Business Companies Entertainment Gaming GTA 6
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Decrypt as “GameStop CEO Says Digital-Only Games Have ‘Hurt Consumers’ as GTA 6 Skips Discs”.