World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Pistorius backs Ukraine’s deep strikes as US warns they risk escalation
Developed over time first seen 1 day ago
Germany’s Defence Minister Boris Pistorius called US criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes on Russia “stupid”, arguing attention should instead focus on Russia’s attacks on Ukrainian energy, water and heating systems. The dispute highlights differing views among Kyiv’s supporters about whether strikes inside Russia weaken its war effort or risk escalating the conflict.
At a NATO meeting in Brussels, Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby said deep strikes had not helped end the war and could harden Russian public and Kremlin resolve, particularly when they hit commercial sites such as Wildberries warehouses. Britain’s Wes Streeting said the strikes had degraded Russia’s war machine, while Ukraine’s defence minister said they were retaliation for Russian attacks, including one on the Crimea bridge. He said Ukraine plans to increase its deep-strike capability more than threefold next year; the meeting also addressed arms supplies ahead of winter as Russia intensified attacks on Ukrainian infrastructure.
- Sources
- 3
- Outlets
- 3
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 1 · 1
In short
- Germany rejected US criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes.
- The US warned the attacks could harden Russian resolve.
- Ukraine plans to expand its strike capability more than threefold.
How this story developed
- 1 day ago Ukraine’s defence minister linked the strikes to Russian attacks, including on civilian infrastructure, and said Kyiv planned to more than triple its deep-strike capacity next year.
- 1 day ago Elbridge Colby specified that strikes on commercial warehouses, including Wildberries, could be counterproductive, while Wes Streeting said Ukrainian attacks had weakened Russia’s war effort and saved lives.
- 1 day ago Boris Pistorius called US criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes “stupid”, as NATO allies split over whether the attacks damage Russia’s war effort or risk escalation.
Full account
German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius has rejected US criticism of Ukraine’s long-range strikes inside Russia, calling it “quite a stupid thing” to criticise attacks on strategic military or military-used targets. His comments came at a meeting of Ukraine’s supporters at Nato headquarters in Brussels on 17 November, where Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby questioned the campaign’s effectiveness and warned it could strengthen Russian resolve.
Colby said the strikes had not brought the war closer to an end or helped blunt Russian advances on the frontline. He urged Western governments to prioritise Ukraine’s frontline defence and medium-range operations that disrupt Russian logistics. He also singled out attacks on commercial sites, including warehouses run by online retailer Wildberries, arguing that such strikes could harden public support for the war. Ukraine says Wildberries facilities supply equipment and components for Russia’s military; the company denies this, according to one report.
Pistorius argued that attention should instead focus on Russia’s repeated attacks on Ukraine’s energy, water and heating systems. British Defence Secretary Wes Streeting also defended Ukraine’s operations, saying they had weakened Russia’s war effort, bought time and saved lives. Ukraine’s Defence Minister, Yevhenii Khmara, described the strikes as a response to Russian attacks and said Kyiv would retaliate more forcefully. He said Ukraine planned to expand its deep-strike capacity by more than threefold next year.
The exchange exposed differing views among Ukraine’s allies about how Kyiv should use its capabilities, amid discussions in Brussels about further military aid, including air defence, before winter. Ukraine has used domestically developed drones and missiles against Russian refineries, military sites and logistics targets. Colby said Ukraine should not be made to fight with its hands tied, while maintaining that frontline defence and strikes against military logistics should take priority.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
The first report foregrounds Pistorius’s sharp language and includes Khmara’s account of Ukraine’s response and planned expansion of deep-strike capacity, as well as a specific reference to the Crimea bridge. The second frames the dispute as evidence of divisions among Ukraine’s allies and gives more detail on Colby’s argument about commercial targets, including Wildberries and the company’s denial of Ukraine’s allegations. The reports also describe the meeting differently: the first calls it a meeting of the Ramstein Group, while the second uses the formal name Ukraine Defense Contact Group.
Centre outlets 1
Only here: hits, russia, rift, tactics
Right-leaning outlets 1
Only here: pistorius, backs, warns, risk, escalation
Every side used: ukraine, deep, strikes
Headline columns compared word for word; nothing in them is AI-written.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Ukraine’s supporters can argue that striking strategic military targets inside Russia is a legitimate way to disrupt the forces and infrastructure sustaining its invasion, especially as Russia attacks Ukrainian cities and energy supplies. They may see deep strikes as both retaliation and a way to raise the cost of continuing the war, while strengthening Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.
The case against
Critics can argue that deep strikes have not brought the war closer to ending and may instead harden Russian resolve or increase the risk of escalation. They may also distinguish military targets from attacks affecting civilian infrastructure, arguing that the latter can cause harm without weakening Russia’s war effort enough to justify the added risks.
Explained simply
Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, and the two countries remain at war. Ukraine’s supporters, including NATO members, provide weapons and other assistance, while seeking to avoid a wider conflict between Russia and NATO.
“Deep strikes” are Ukrainian attacks on targets well inside Russia, including military facilities and infrastructure. Supporters say they can disrupt Russia’s ability to wage war; critics warn that some attacks may strengthen Russian resolve or increase the risk of escalation. The disagreement matters as Ukraine seeks more capacity for such strikes and its allies weigh how to support its defence.
Coverage · 3 sources
Bias meters
From 2 rated sources, 1 unrated.
Americas Europe Russia-Ukraine War World
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “German defence chief condemns ‘stupid’ US criticism of Ukraine’s deep strikes into Russia after Pentagon told Europe to stop ‘poking’ Kremlin”.