Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
GTA 6 PS5 Review Bombing Out of Control as Zelda Receives Revenge Ratings
GTA 6 has been targeted by a wave of zero-star user reviews on Metacritic, prompting what appears to be a retaliatory ratings campaign against The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. The dispute highlights how user scores can become a battleground between fan groups and may not reliably reflect players’ overall views.
GTA 6’s Metacritic user score stood at 5.4, despite a critics’ average of 99. The Zelda remake’s user score fell from 9.6 to 8.9, with at least one review explicitly calling it payback. Some GTA 6 reviews cite its 30fps performance, story or life-simulation elements, while the PlayStation Store rating was 4.84 from about 170,000 reviews.
In short
- GTA 6 is receiving coordinated zero-score reviews on Metacritic.
- Zelda’s user score fell from 9.6 to 8.9 amid apparent retaliation.
- GTA 6’s PlayStation Store rating is 4.84 from 170,000 reviews.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
User reviews can give players a way to register dissatisfaction that critics’ scores may miss, including concerns about performance, story or gameplay. Even when some ratings are retaliatory, visible score changes can draw attention to fan behaviour and prompt platforms to consider how well their systems distinguish genuine reviews from coordinated campaigns.
The case against
A flood of zero-star ratings, especially when reviews openly describe them as payback, can distort scores and make them a poor guide to players’ overall experience. Critics’ and platform ratings offer useful context, but they also have limitations and may not capture every player’s priorities; the reported figures alone cannot establish whether the user scores are representative.
Explained simply
Metacritic is a website that collects reviews of films, games and other media. It shows professional critics’ scores separately from ratings submitted by users, who can give a game a score directly on its page.
GTA 6 is a major PlayStation 5 game, while The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time is a long-running Nintendo game with a large fan community. When groups of users give a game very low or very high scores in response to a dispute, the resulting score may reflect that campaign as well as players’ views of the game itself.
User ratings can offer a sense of audience reaction, but they are not the same as a representative survey. Differences between platforms, and between critics’ and users’ scores, can also make ratings harder to compare.