Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Gun Rights and Guilt by Association
The Ninth Circuit has ruled that Kenneth Shilling can pursue a First Amendment claim after San Diego County revoked his concealed-carry licence because of his membership in the Boozefighters Motorcycle Club. The decision matters because it says the county cannot deny a benefit solely on the basis of association with an alleged criminal group without considering the individual’s intent and conduct.
Shilling, who has no criminal record, received his licence in June 2022 under California’s then-existing “good moral character” requirement. Sheriff Kelly Martinez revoked it in December 2023, describing the club as a “criminal street gang”; Shilling was not given a chance to contest the allegations beforehand, though he could seek reconsideration. The appeals court said he had sufficiently alleged that the revocation infringed his freedom of association, allowing that claim to proceed.
In short
- San Diego revoked Shilling’s carry licence over his motorcycle-club membership.
- The Ninth Circuit allowed his freedom-of-association claim to proceed.
- The court said association alone may not justify denying a right.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A person should not lose a government-issued licence merely because they belong to a group accused of criminal activity. The First Amendment protects association, and considering an individual’s own intent and conduct helps prevent guilt by association and arbitrary decisions, especially when the person has no criminal record and was not heard before the revocation.
The case against
Public authorities have a duty to assess risks when issuing concealed-carry licences, and credible evidence about a group’s criminal activity may be relevant to that assessment. Requiring an individualised review need not mean ignoring those risks; officials can argue that swift action is justified to protect public safety, provided the decision can be properly reviewed.