Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Hollywood actor seeks help from vicar for series
A Shropshire vicar and environmental campaigner, the Rev Paul Cawthorne, helped Michael Sheen investigate former toxic waste sites for a new BBC documentary. He is calling for a fresh statutory investigation into Stoney Hill landfill near Coalbrookdale after historical records indicated that Monsanto legally disposed of waste there during the 1980s.
Cawthorne says testing linked to the investigation found dangerously high levels of polychlorinated biphenyls at nine of 10 sites examined, although the findings concern several locations rather than Stoney Hill alone. Telford and Wrekin Council says its records show no evidence of toxic waste at Stoney Hill and that regular monitoring has found no cause for concern; an Environment Agency review in 2008 also concluded the site was not harming the local environment. The two-part series, *Buried with Michael Sheen*, begins on BBC Two, BBC One Wales and iPlayer on 17 August.
In short
- Vicar urges renewed inquiry into former Shropshire landfill.
- Documentary examines alleged historic chemical waste disposal.
- Council says monitoring shows no environmental concern.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Those calling for a fresh investigation argue that documented evidence of Monsanto's legal waste disposal at Stoney Hill during the 1980s, combined with testing showing dangerously high PCB levels at nearby sites, justifies renewed scrutiny under the precautionary principle. Given the serious health risks posed by PCBs and the time elapsed since the previous 2008 Environment Agency review, they contend that current monitoring and historical assessments may be insufficient and that local residents deserve a thorough contemporary investigation to establish whether historical contamination poses ongoing environmental or health risks.
The case against
Those favouring the current position argue that the Council's records specifically show no evidence of toxic waste at Stoney Hill, regular ongoing monitoring has identified no cause for concern, and a formal Environment Agency review already concluded the site was not harming the local environment. They point out that the PCB findings mentioned concern several other locations rather than Stoney Hill itself, and that without specific evidence of current harm at this particular site, reopening investigations based on historical disposal records alone would represent poor allocation of regulatory resources when existing oversight structures are functioning adequately.
Explained simply
Landfill sites are places where rubbish is buried, and some older sites may have received industrial waste as well as household rubbish. Polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, are chemicals once used in industry that can persist in the environment and may pose health risks.
The Rev Paul Cawthorne is a Shropshire vicar and environmental campaigner who has researched former waste sites with actor Michael Sheen. Monsanto, a chemicals company, is named in historical records concerning waste disposal at Stoney Hill near Coalbrookdale.
Evidence about several sites, including reported PCB test results, has prompted calls for further investigation. Telford and Wrekin Council and an earlier Environment Agency review have said they found no evidence of harm at Stoney Hill, leaving differing accounts of the site’s history and condition.
Celebrity Entertainment Film Science TV