World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Homeless man accused in Chinatown killing released day before attack — despite DA asking for him to be held on bail
Alexander Florentino, 25, was released on supervised conditions by a Manhattan judge on Thursday, a day before police say he killed a woman in her Chinatown home. Prosecutors had asked for bail, and the case has raised questions about how decisions are made when defendants have multiple pending cases and missed court appearances.
Florentino had appeared on petty theft and stolen-property charges, with several other cases pending and warrants issued after he failed to appear, according to the article. Prosecutors sought $3,000 cash bail or a $9,000 bond, but Judge Juliet Howard ordered supervised release. Police say Florentino broke into the 62-year-old woman’s Catherine Street apartment on Friday, killed her and struck her roommate with a bottle; he now faces murder and burglary charges.
In short
- Florentino was released on supervised conditions before the alleged killing.
- Prosecutors had requested $3,000 bail or a $9,000 bond.
- He is charged with murder and burglary.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A judge may reasonably have concluded that supervised release was proportionate for the theft and stolen-property charges before her, especially if the law limited detention based on the alleged offences and the evidence of risk. Release conditions can preserve a presumption of innocence while allowing monitoring, and bail decisions should not be made as though a later alleged crime were already known.
The case against
Prosecutors could reasonably argue that the pending cases and missed court appearances showed a substantial risk of further non-appearance or harm, making supervised release inadequate. They sought a relatively modest bail amount, and the killing alleged to have occurred the next day has intensified scrutiny of whether the court had enough information and tools to assess risk across multiple cases.