World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Hoping for Britain to rejoin the EU with Andy Burnham? You may be waiting a long time | Timothy Garton Ash
Andy Burnham’s first major speech on Britain’s relationship with Europe disappointed those hoping it would signal a path back into the EU. He said the UK had lost more than it gained over the past decade, but ruled out major changes during this parliament, keeping the government’s existing red lines in place.
At a UK-EU summit on Friday, the two sides are expected to discuss easier trade in food and agricultural products, linking carbon markets and a youth mobility scheme. Burnham said he would examine longer-term options to inform decisions in the next parliament, likely no earlier than 2029. The article says domestic political caution and uncertainty about public support for rejoining help explain the limited proposals.
In short
- Burnham’s speech offered no near-term route to EU membership.
- Modest UK-EU agreements are expected at Friday’s summit.
- Longer-term options may inform decisions after 2029.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A cautious, incremental approach may be the most credible way to improve relations with the EU while respecting current political constraints. Practical agreements on food trade, carbon markets and youth mobility could deliver benefits and build public confidence, while examining longer-term options leaves future governments room to act when support is clearer.
The case against
Keeping the government’s red lines and postponing major choices risks prolonging economic and diplomatic costs that the article says Britain has incurred since Brexit. Those who favour rejoining or closer alignment may argue that leadership should make the case for a more ambitious relationship now, rather than letting uncertainty about public opinion defer the debate until at least 2029.
Explained simply
Britain left the European Union in 2020, after the 2016 referendum in which a narrow majority voted to leave. The UK and EU have since agreed rules for trade and cooperation, while the UK remains outside the EU’s single market and customs union.
Andy Burnham is the Labour mayor of Greater Manchester and a prominent voice in the party. Labour’s government has said it wants a closer relationship with the EU, while ruling out rejoining the single market or customs union and restoring free movement.
The debate matters because changes to the relationship can affect trade, travel and work between Britain and EU countries. Any move towards rejoining would also depend on political support in the UK and agreement with EU members.
Business Europe Government Politics UK World