World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
How wildfire litigation became big business in America
The 2018 Camp Fire, started when a power line owned by Pacific Gas and Electric (PG&E) broke and ignited dry brush, killed 85 people and destroyed more than 18,000 structures. PG&E later agreed to pay $13.5 billion to settle claims over that fire and other blazes, helping establish large utility lawsuits as a way to compensate wildfire victims.
Since 2017, more than $18 billion has been awarded or agreed in wildfire settlements in California, Hawaiʻi, Colorado and Oregon, with several major utilities facing claims. More than 9 million acres had burned across the US by October, around 1.5 times the decade average for that point in the year. The article questions whether litigation is a sustainable or fair response as climate change increases the chance that small fires become destructive, more homes are built in fire-prone areas, and insurers retreat from those places.
In short
- PG&E’s Camp Fire settlement helped spur major wildfire lawsuits.
- More than $18 billion in claims has been settled or awarded since 2017.
- Litigation may leave victims dependent on whether a utility caused the fire.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Large settlements can give people who have lost homes, livelihoods or loved ones a route to compensation when a utility’s equipment is found to have caused a fire. The prospect of liability can also press utilities to maintain infrastructure and account for the risks their operations impose on communities, while spreading some costs beyond victims and taxpayers.
The case against
Large-scale litigation may provide an uncertain and uneven way to address fires whose damage can reflect many factors, including worsening fire conditions and development in high-risk areas. Very large liabilities may strain utilities and ultimately raise bills or affect services, while settlements alone do little to reduce exposure through prevention, land-use decisions or better insurance arrangements.