Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Hundreds of SEND children could be abandoned under Milburn reforms, campaigners fear
Alan Milburn’s proposals to reduce the number of under-25s not in education, employment or training have prompted concern that children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND) could be blamed for not taking up opportunities, despite councils failing to provide adequate support. Campaigners say the reforms risk overlooking how gaps in education and support contribute to young people becoming classified as not in education, employment or training.
They point to 18-year-old Ella Sanwalka, who has had almost no formal education and made several suicide attempts while waiting for Surrey County Council to provide support. Although the council agreed an education, health and care plan in 2021, it has not yet been implemented and a tribunal decision is pending. A campaign group gathered 1,253 family accounts covering 134 councils; a separate analysis of 1,706 accounts found that 354 described periods with no school place or educational provision.
In short
- Campaigners fear SEND pupils may be overlooked in Milburn’s proposed reforms.
- Ella Sanwalka has had almost no formal education despite an agreed support plan.
- Families reported education failures across 134 councils.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Reducing the number of young people not in education, employment or training could help more under-25s access opportunities and avoid being left without a route into adult life. Supporters could argue that reforms are justified if they identify young people at risk earlier and improve coordination between services, while keeping expectations of participation clear.
The case against
If the reforms focus on young people’s participation without ensuring suitable education and support are actually available, children with SEND may be unfairly treated as responsible for circumstances beyond their control. The reported accounts of missing provision and unimplemented education plans suggest that councils’ failures can contribute to young people becoming NEET, so campaigners argue reform must address those gaps rather than simply pressuring individuals.
Explained simply
SEND stands for special educational needs and disabilities. Some children need extra help or tailored teaching to take part in education, and councils in England may set out that support in an education, health and care plan.
Alan Milburn has proposed measures to reduce the number of young people under 25 who are not in education, employment or training. The term describes a broad group, including people who may be out of work or study for different reasons.
The debate is about how responsibility for that situation is assessed when support has not been provided. Families and campaigners say gaps in education and help can leave young people with SEND without a route into further study or work.