Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
I Photographed Her Parents as They Were Sentenced for Her Twin’s Death. Years Later, I Photographed Her Life.
A photographer who captured the sentencing of Travis and Sarah Mitchell has returned years later to document the life of their surviving twin, Evelyn. The story follows Evelyn and her guardians, Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, as they leave the Followers of Christ faith-healing sect, and shows how the family’s experience connects to wider questions about child protection and religious exemptions.
In 2017, the Mitchells did not seek medical care for premature twins who were struggling to breathe: Ginnifer died after four hours, while authorities eventually insisted Evelyn be taken to hospital. The couple pleaded guilty to criminally negligent homicide and criminal mistreatment and received prison sentences of more than six years. Evelyn, now 9, has remained in the Phillipses’ care; the reporting also compares Oregon’s legal changes with Idaho’s broader exemptions, which can limit intervention to protect children.
In short
- A photojournalist revisits the surviving twin years after her sister’s death.
- Evelyn is now 9 and lives with guardians who left the sect.
- The story examines how state laws shape child protection.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Religious freedom and parental authority deserve protection, including the ability to make sincere decisions about a child’s care without unnecessary state intrusion. Supporters of exemptions may argue that broad rules risk treating religious families unfairly, and that intervention should be based on clear evidence of serious danger rather than belief alone.
The case against
Children have their own interests and need timely medical care, and the state has a duty to protect them when adults’ choices put their lives at serious risk. Critics of broad religious exemptions argue that faith should not shield neglect from child-protection laws, and that consistent safeguards are needed regardless of a family’s beliefs.
Explained simply
The Followers of Christ is a small Christian group known for relying on prayer rather than medical treatment in some cases. Oregon and Idaho have laws on when parents can refuse medical care for their children, including religious exemptions that can affect when authorities step in.
Travis and Sarah Mitchell’s premature twin daughters, Ginnifer and Evelyn, were born in 2017. Ginnifer died without receiving medical care; Evelyn was taken to hospital and survived. The Mitchells later pleaded guilty to crimes connected with their daughters’ treatment.
Evelyn was placed in the care of Marshall and Jennifer Phillips, who became her guardians. Her story raises questions about how child protection laws balance parental religious beliefs with children’s need for medical care, and how those laws differ between states.