Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Anthony Ippolito Channels Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s Cleverly Crafted Crowd-Pleaser About the Making of ‘Rocky’
Developed over time first seen 2 months ago
Variety's review of Peter Farrelly's "I Play Rocky" praises Anthony Ippolito's performance as Sylvester Stallone, arguing that the film's success hinges on an uncanny physical and vocal impersonation that goes beyond mimicry to capture the actor's stubborn, dogged character. The review situates the film within a broader appreciation for "Rocky", which turns 50 this November, and argues it succeeds by dramatising the chaotic, improvisational circumstances of the original film's creation rather than simply restaging it, drawing a comparison with Richard Linklater's 2025 drama "Nouvelle Vague".
Written by Peter Gamble, the film traces Stallone from a penniless, struggling actor in 1974 New York, reduced to auditioning for bit parts and living in a fleabag hotel, through his relationship with Sasha (played by AnnaSophia Robb), who encourages him to write his own starring role. The pair marry and move to Los Angeles, where Stallone works as a parking attendant while continuing to write, until his breakthrough moment on 24 March 1975, when he watches underdog boxer Chuck Wepner's title fight against Muhammad Ali on a bar television — the real-life bout credited with inspiring the "Rocky" story.
- Sources
- 4
- Outlets
- 4
- Left · Centre · Right
- 0 · 0 · 0
In short
- Variety review praises Anthony Ippolito's uncanny performance as Sylvester Stallone
- Film dramatises Stallone's struggles before writing and starring in "Rocky"
- Chuck Wepner's 1975 fight with Ali is shown as the story's inspiration
How this story developed
- 2 months ago Variety's review of Peter Farrelly's "I Play Rocky" reveals new plot detail: after moving to Los Angeles with his wife Sasha and working as a parking attendant while continuing to write scripts, Sylvester Stallone's breakthrough moment comes on 24 March 1975, when he watches underdog Chuck Wepner's title fight against Muhammad Ali on a bar television — the real-life event that is said to have inspired the "Rocky" story.
- 2 months ago Variety's review of Peter Farrelly's "I Play Rocky" praises Anthony Ippolito's performance as Sylvester Stallone, arguing that the film's success hinges on an uncanny physical and vocal impersonation that goes beyond mimicry to capture the actor's stubborn, dogged character.
- 2 months ago Variety's review of Peter Farrelly's "I Play Rocky" adds further detail beyond the initial coverage, praising Anthony Ippolito's performance as Sylvester Stallone as more than mere impersonation, capturing his droopy eyes, jutting lips and even skin tone alongside a note-perfect recreation of his low, mumbling voice.
- 2 months ago Variety's review of Peter Farrelly's "I Play Rocky" praises the film's account of how a struggling Sylvester Stallone conceived, wrote and fought to star in "Rocky" in the mid-1970s, singling out Anthony Ippolito's performance as Stallone for its remarkably accurate look and voice.
- 2 months ago Variety's review praises Peter Farrelly's new film "I Play Rocky," a biographical drama depicting how a struggling young Sylvester Stallone conceived, wrote and fought to star in "Rocky" in the mid-1970s.
- Deadline ‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Peter Farrelly’s Sensational Biopic Of The Making Of Stallone’s Classic Is Just As Inspiring As The Original Movie Itself – Toronto Film Festival
- Collider 'I Play Rocky' Is Officially a Knockout | TIFF Review
- The Hollywood Reporter ‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Anthony Ippolito Is an Endearing Pre-Stardom Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s Crowd-Pleasing Making-Of Drama
- Variety ‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Anthony Ippolito Channels Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s Cleverly Crafted Crowd-Pleaser About the Making of ‘Rocky’
Full account
A new biographical drama, "I Play Rocky," directed by Peter Farrelly and written by Peter Gamble, dramatises the unlikely true story of how Sylvester Stallone came to write, sell and star in "Rocky," the 1976 boxing film that turned him into one of Hollywood's biggest stars. Reviewers who have seen the film describe it as a crowd-pleasing account of Stallone's rise from struggling actor to Oscar-winning screenwriter and leading man, arriving in the year that marks the 50th anniversary of the original "Rocky"'s release this November.
Central to both reviews is praise for Anthony Ippolito's performance as the young Stallone, referred to in the film by his birth name Michael, or 'Mike'. Critics single out his physical resemblance and vocal impersonation as remarkably convincing, with one describing the effect as though de-ageing technology had been used to let Stallone play himself decades younger, and another noting the precise recreation of his features, colouring and distinctive low, drawling voice. Both accounts stress that the performance goes beyond mimicry, capturing the doggedness and stubborn optimism of the man he once was, and that Farrelly reportedly would not have proceeded with the project without Stallone's own blessing, which he secured.
The narrative traces Stallone's circumstances in New York in the mid-1970s: living in cheap lodgings, auditioning for minor and demeaning parts (including a scene depicting a real audition for a soft pornography role), adopting a stray dog he named Butkus, and meeting his future wife at the cinema where he worked. It follows him through repeated rejection, including losing out on a role after another actor was cast in a related part, before his fortunes turn when he secures a meeting with producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff, portrayed in the film by PJ Byrne and Toby Kebbell respectively, with AnnaSophia Robb playing his love interest. The story builds towards Stallone's insistence on starring in his own screenplay despite lucrative offers to sell it outright without him attached, a gamble now regarded as one of the more remarkable in film history.
Both reviews are broadly positive, framing the film as a well-constructed piece of filmmaking about filmmaking, though they draw slightly different comparisons and emphasise different things. One situates the film alongside Richard Linklater's 2025 drama "Nouvelle Vague," about the making of Jean-Luc Godard's "Breathless," suggesting both pictures succeed by capturing the improvisational spirit that shaped the finished classics they depict. The other draws attention to a post-credits scene showing archival footage of Stallone's first appearance on "The Tonight Show," in which host Johnny Carson remarks that a film about the making of "Rocky" would be too far-fetched to be believed — a moment that reviewer frames as prophetic validation of the project. That review also places greater emphasis on the film's fidelity to real events and its place within the wider "Rocky" and "Creed" franchise legacy, while the other focuses more closely on the craft of Ippolito's performance and the screenplay's structure.
Where outlets differ
From the full account, which is AI-written from the sources:
One review draws a comparison to Richard Linklater's 'Nouvelle Vague' as a stylistic touchstone for films about the making of other films; the other instead highlights a post-credits archival clip of Stallone on 'The Tonight Show' with Johnny Carson as a standout element.
One source frames the film primarily through Ippolito's performance and the screenplay's craftsmanship, while the other gives more attention to the film's place within the 50-year 'Rocky'/'Creed' franchise history and its fidelity to real events (e.g. the soft pornography audition anecdote).
One review notes Farrelly required Stallone's blessing to proceed, a production detail not mentioned in the other excerpt.
The excerpts differ in plot detail — one focuses more on mood and atmosphere (the fleabag hotel, the stray dog) while the other itemises specific plot beats including the producers' names and casting choices.
Explained simply
Rocky turns 50 this November, and Peter Farrelly's new film "I Play Rocky" tells the story of how that original boxing drama came to exist. It focuses on Sylvester Stallone, then a little-known actor struggling to get more than minor parts, who wrote the "Rocky" script himself and fought to be cast in the lead role rather than let a studio give it to a bigger star.
The film, reviewed here by Variety, stars Anthony Ippolito as the young Stallone, with AnnaSophia Robb playing his partner Sasha, who pushes him to write his own material. It follows the couple from a rundown New York flophouse in 1974 to Los Angeles, where Stallone worked as a parking attendant while writing, eventually finding his story's spark while watching a real 1975 heavyweight title fight between Muhammad Ali and underdog Chuck Wepner.
The film matters as a making-of story behind one of Hollywood's most enduring underdog tales, timed to coincide with "Rocky"'s 50th anniversary and inviting comparison between the hardships Stallone faced and the fictional boxer he went on to create.
Coverage · 4 sources
- Variety‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Anthony Ippolito Channels Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s Cleverly Crafted Crowd-Pleaser About the Making of ‘Rocky’
- Deadline‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Peter Farrelly’s Sensational Biopic Of The Making Of Stallone’s Classic Is Just As Inspiring As The Original Movie Itself – Toronto Film Festival
- Collider'I Play Rocky' Is Officially a Knockout | TIFF Review
- The Hollywood Reporter‘I Play Rocky’ Review: Anthony Ippolito Is an Endearing Pre-Stardom Sylvester Stallone in Peter Farrelly’s Crowd-Pleasing Making-Of Drama