“If that had been me…”: what if Emma Thompson didn’t turn down Sharon Stone’s ‘Basic Instinct’ role?
Emma Thompson was considered for Catherine Tramell in *Basic Instinct* but turned the role down; Sharon Stone went on to play the character in the 1992 thriller. The casting alternative invites speculation about how Thompson’s career might have changed, particularly as *Howard’s End*, released the same year, earned her an Academy Award.
Stone’s performance became a career breakthrough, and the film’s leg-crossing scene became notorious. Stone later said she had been told the scene would not show her body, and described discovering otherwise during a screening. Thompson joked that the film’s sex scene would have been physically chaotic for her; the article suggests she has had no evident reason to regret her choice.
- Emma Thompson turned down Catherine Tramell in *Basic Instinct*.
- Sharon Stone’s role became a breakthrough, despite controversy over a scene.
- Thompson won an Oscar for *Howard’s End* in the same year.
New here? Start with this
Basic Instinct, released in 1992, was a thriller that became a landmark film in cinema. Emma Thompson was considered for the lead role of Catherine Tramell but declined the part. Sharon Stone was cast instead, and the film achieved major commercial and cultural success.
Stone's performance became a breakthrough moment that significantly raised her profile, and the film is particularly remembered for its controversial content. Thompson instead starred in Howard's End that same year, which won her an Academy Award. The two actresses' careers consequently took very different paths from that decision point.
The story invites reflection on how a single choice can shape professional trajectories. Both actresses went on to achieve success, but the particular direction each career took was partly determined by who accepted or declined this role at a crucial moment.