Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In 1969, The Who came up with a song that Pete Townshend could never write. Decades later, he still finds it too disturbing
Pete Townshend shaped most of The Who’s music and conceived *Tommy* as a continuous rock opera, but he could not bring himself to write “Fiddle About”. The song depicts the sexual abuse of Tommy by his Uncle Ernie, a disturbing part of the story that Townshend felt he could not perform with sufficient cruelty.
Bassist John Entwistle completed the song, which makes the abuse explicit after other tracks have established Tommy’s trauma. Townshend said he did not want to perform those songs, though he recognised their starkness conveyed how cruelly Tommy was treated and dismissed as a “freak”. The article also presents Entwistle as an important creative force in the band, whose songs and playing helped shape its catalogue.
In short
- Townshend could not write “Fiddle About”.
- John Entwistle completed the song for *Tommy*.
- Its depiction of abuse made the rock opera especially disturbing.
Explained simply
The Who were a British rock band whose guitarist Pete Townshend wrote much of their music. In 1969 they released Tommy, a rock opera: an album whose songs follow one connected story about a boy called Tommy.
The story follows Tommy after childhood trauma leaves him unable to see, hear or speak, while those around him treat him as an outsider. “Fiddle About” portrays abuse by his uncle Ernie, and was written by bassist John Entwistle rather than Townshend. Entwistle’s contribution helps explain how the band’s music and storytelling were shaped by more than one songwriter.