In 1975, Paul Simon sold 5,000,000 copies of a song he called “too weird to be a hit”
In 1975, Paul Simon's "50 Ways to Leave Your Lover" sold 5 million copies, despite Simon's belief that it was too unconventional to become a hit. The musician initially expected "Kodachrome" to be his commercial breakthrough and considered "50 Ways" too strange—with unusual chords and a downtempo style that contradicted the radio hits of the era.
The song's verses featured complex, non-repeating chord progressions with unexpected harmonic extensions that seemed out of place on typical pop records of the time. Yet the memorable, straightforward chorus provided the bridge between Simon's experimental verses and mass appeal, allowing audiences to simply sing along despite the sophistication underlying the song.
- Paul Simon doubted "50 Ways" would be a hit, yet it sold 5 million copies.
- Song featured unusual, non-repetitive chord progressions unlike typical pop hits.
- Catchy chorus made complex verses appealing to mainstream audiences.
New here? Start with this
Paul Simon was an established American singer-songwriter with a history of musical experimentation. He had already achieved significant commercial success both as part of the 1960s duo Simon and Garfunkel and as a solo artist during the 1970s.
The mid-1970s pop music landscape was characterised by certain commercial conventions. Industry professionals often believed that songs with unconventional musical elements were too risky to become mainstream radio hits.
Simon's belief that "50 Ways to Leave Your Lover" was unsuitable for commercial success reflected these broader industry assumptions about what audiences wanted to hear. The song's eventual commercial performance thus represented a notable challenge to those prevailing expectations at the time.