Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In 1994, Paul Newman starred in a movie “tailored to him” in every way. He turned down a reunion with Robert Redford to make it
Paul Newman chose to star in *Nobody’s Fool* in 1994, missing the chance to appear in Robert Redford’s *Quiz Show*. The decision matters because it was one of the few opportunities for the celebrated screen duo to work together again, but they never made a third film.
Writer-director Robert Benton said he had Newman in mind for every line of *Nobody’s Fool* and did not know what he would have done if Newman had declined. Newman was offered the role of Mark Van Doren in *Quiz Show*, but the long rehearsal period for *Nobody’s Fool* prevented him from taking both parts. Paul Scofield replaced him and received an Oscar nomination for supporting actor; Newman was nominated for best actor for *Nobody’s Fool*.
In short
- Newman chose *Nobody’s Fool* over a role in *Quiz Show*.
- Benton wrote the lead role with Newman specifically in mind.
- Newman and Redford never made a third film together.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Choosing Nobody’s Fool let Newman take a role written with his particular qualities in mind and commit fully to Benton’s long rehearsal process. The film gave him a leading performance recognised with a best actor Oscar nomination, and accepting it was a sound artistic choice even though it meant passing on another prestigious part.
The case against
Taking Quiz Show would have reunited Newman with Robert Redford, a rare opportunity for two actors whose earlier films together had made their partnership memorable. Newman’s absence meant the pairing never got a third film, and the role went to Paul Scofield, whose performance earned an Oscar nomination; from that perspective, the reunion’s lost possibility was a meaningful cost.
Explained simply
Paul Newman was a major American film actor whose career spanned several decades. Robert Redford was another leading actor of his generation, and the two had starred together in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid and The Sting.
Nobody’s Fool is a drama written and directed by Robert Benton, with Newman playing Sully, a man living in a small New York town. Quiz Show, directed by Redford, tells the story of a television quiz-show scandal in the 1950s; Mark Van Doren was a real academic caught up in it. The two films brought Newman different roles, and the choice between them touched on the possibility of another Newman-Redford screen pairing.