World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In 2002, Slash met “one of America’s classic artists”, only to be erased from the song they made
In 2002, Slash recorded with Ray Charles, whom he regarded as one of America’s classic artists and a pioneer for Black music on the radio. The collaboration mattered to Slash because he was a longtime admirer of Charles, though one of his guitar parts was later removed from the released version of “Sorry Seems to Be the Hardest Word”.
Slash said he played on the song, but after Charles’s death an executive producer replaced his part with one by a friend, despite Charles reportedly finding Slash’s playing more bluesy. The sessions also challenged Slash, who was more accustomed to relying on instinct than reading sheet music, but he said the experience did not lessen his respect for Charles.
In short
- Slash recorded with Ray Charles in 2002.
- His guitar part was later replaced on one song.
- The experience left his admiration for Charles intact.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Replacing Slash’s guitar part could be defended as an artistic decision by the executive producer, who may have believed the released arrangement worked better with the replacement performance. A producer is responsible for shaping a recording, and Charles’s reported preference during the sessions need not settle what best served the final version.
The case against
Slash’s contribution could reasonably be seen as part of the collaboration Charles had invited and valued, particularly given the report that Charles found his playing more bluesy. Replacing it after Charles’s death, especially with a friend’s part, may therefore seem to disregard the original artistic relationship and Charles’s expressed musical preference.
Americas Entertainment Music World