Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In 2011, Colin Farrell’s first reaction to being offered a movie was, “Ewww”. He should have trusted his gut
In 2011, Colin Farrell was offered a role in a remake of the science-fiction film Total Recall, despite his initial reaction being “Ewww, really… OK?” He went ahead after liking the script, but the article argues the film’s poor reception showed that his first doubts were justified.
Farrell had already starred in the 2011 Fright Night reboot, which received mostly favourable reviews and made modestly at the box office. Directed by Len Wiseman, Total Recall also earned a decent opening weekend, but critics faulted it for lacking the humour and engaging characters of the 1987 Arnold Schwarzenegger original. Farrell later appeared in Tim Burton’s poorly received Dumbo remake in 2019.
In short
- Farrell hesitated before signing on to Total Recall.
- The 2012 remake drew criticism for lacking the original’s humour.
- He later starred in the poorly received Dumbo remake.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Farrell’s hesitation may have been a sound instinct: remaking a well-loved film risks inviting unfavourable comparisons, and critics felt this version lost much of the original’s humour and appeal. His later involvement in another poorly received remake may reinforce the case for being cautious when a project’s premise feels unpromising, even if its script initially persuades.
The case against
An actor can reasonably judge a role by the script and the creative possibilities, rather than reject it solely because it is a remake. Total Recall opened strongly, and its mixed reception does not prove Farrell’s initial reaction was a reliable guide; commercial performance and artistic merit can diverge, while taking varied roles may be worthwhile even when a film does not satisfy critics.
Explained simply
Total Recall is a science-fiction story about a man whose memories and sense of identity are called into question. The 2012 film starring Colin Farrell was a remake of a 1987 film led by Arnold Schwarzenegger, which had become well known for mixing action with humour.
Farrell was already an established actor, and the remake was directed by Len Wiseman. Remakes revisit familiar stories, often drawing audiences who know the earlier version; that can make comparisons with the original part of how a new film is received.
The film’s reception mattered to Farrell’s career and to discussion of how remakes fare with audiences and critics. He later appeared in another remake, Tim Burton’s Dumbo, released in 2019.