Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In 2015, Gerard Butler made his most controversial movie. He doesn’t regret it, but the director felt compelled to apologise
Gerard Butler’s 2016 fantasy film *Gods of Egypt* faced strong criticism for casting mostly white actors as Egyptian deities, renewing concerns about representation in Hollywood. The studio and director Alex Proyas apologised before release, while Butler defended the casting and said he disagreed with the backlash.
Seven of the film’s eight main roles went to white actors; Chadwick Boseman was the only established star who did not, and his role was also criticised. The film received poor reviews, lost almost $100 million and earned five Golden Raspberry nominations, including for Butler and Proyas. Butler continued his action-film career, while Proyas has not directed a major film since.
In short
- *Gods of Egypt* drew backlash over its casting.
- Lionsgate and director Alex Proyas apologised before release.
- The film lost almost $100 million and received five Razzie nominations.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Critics argue that casting mostly white actors as Egyptian deities in a story rooted in Egyptian culture excluded actors of colour from prominent roles and reinforced a wider pattern of Hollywood overlooking them. The criticism also reflects a view that studios should take greater care with representation, particularly when adapting stories from cultures whose people have been underrepresented on screen.
The case against
Defenders of the casting argue that actors should be chosen for their suitability to the roles, and that a fantasy film need not be limited to performers of a particular ethnicity. They may also see the backlash as placing too much weight on casting choices, while overlooking other creative considerations and the freedom of filmmakers to interpret ancient myths.
Explained simply
Ancient Egypt was home to a complex society whose people worshipped many gods, often shown in human or animal form. Stories about these deities have been adapted for film, but casting choices can raise questions about whose cultures and histories are represented on screen.
Hollywood has faced repeated criticism over the under-representation of people of colour and the casting of white actors in roles connected to other cultures. In a film about Egyptian gods, those choices drew attention to the relationship between historical setting, fictional storytelling and representation.