Science news and discussion on TalkFuse.
In Utah, a ‘hydrocarbon highway’ could run right through this petroglyph-filled canyon
The Bureau of Land Management approved a plan to blast, widen and pave a road through Gate Canyon in Utah, linking Uinta Basin oil fields to rail facilities. Environmental and historic preservation groups have sued the federal agency, arguing the approval skipped required review and could damage the archaeological and cultural landscape of nearby Nine Mile Canyon.
Nine Mile Canyon stretches about 46 miles and is known for ancient petroglyphs, Native American panels and historic inscriptions. The proposed route crosses 5.3 miles of public and state land and could bring up to 500 heavy trucks through the area each day; Gate Canyon has 47 historic sites, 43 considered eligible for the National Register of Historic Places. The BLM approved the latest plan on 28 April, finding it would not significantly affect the environment, while the groups say it breaches several federal laws.
In short
- Utah groups are challenging approval of a road through Gate Canyon.
- The route could bring up to 500 heavy trucks a day.
- The lawsuit cites risks to historic sites and cultural landscapes.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters could argue that improving the road would provide a practical link between Uinta Basin oil fields and rail facilities, supporting energy production and transport while concentrating truck traffic on a designated route. They may also point to the BLM’s finding that the approved plan would not significantly affect the environment, and argue that infrastructure can proceed with safeguards while respecting heritage sites.
The case against
Opponents could argue that blasting and widening a road through a canyon with dozens of historic sites risks lasting damage to archaeological resources and a culturally important landscape, with up to 500 heavy trucks a day adding pressure. They may also contend that the BLM’s approval did not meet required legal review, so the plan should be reconsidered before construction risks harm that cannot be undone.
Explained simply
Nine Mile Canyon in eastern Utah is a long canyon known for rock art made by Indigenous people, as well as historic inscriptions. Gate Canyon is nearby and contains dozens of historic sites, some considered eligible for the US National Register of Historic Places, which recognises places with cultural or historical importance.
The proposed road would connect oil fields in the Uinta Basin with rail facilities, allowing oil to be carried by truck to trains. The route would cross public and state land, and could be used by as many as 500 heavy trucks a day.
The Bureau of Land Management manages the federal land involved. The dispute centres on whether its review adequately considered possible effects on historic sites and the surrounding landscape; environmental and preservation groups say federal laws required more review.