World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Iran’s Ghalibaf warns US, Israel against targeting civilian infrastructure
Iranian negotiator Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf has warned the United States and Israel against treating civilian infrastructure as a military target. His comments respond to a New York Times report citing analysts who described dams near Iranian missile sites as “dual-use”, a claim Ghalibaf said could be applied in return to facilities near US or Israeli bases.
Ghalibaf named dams, ports and power plants, saying Iran would apply that reasoning “consistently and even-handedly”. The article says the US and Israel have attacked civilian areas and infrastructure across the region on military-use grounds, and reports civilian deaths and injuries in Gaza, Lebanon and Iran.
In short
- Ghalibaf warned against targeting civilian infrastructure.
- His remarks followed a report about dams near Iranian missile sites.
- He said Iran could use the same “dual-use” logic near US or Israeli bases.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The strongest case for treating some infrastructure as a military target is that facilities such as ports, power plants or dams may materially support military operations, even if they also serve civilians. If a specific facility makes a substantial contribution to military action, advocates may argue that striking it can be lawful and strategically necessary, provided the expected civilian harm is proportionate and feasible precautions are taken.
The case against
The strongest case against targeting such infrastructure is that it is essential to civilian life, so damage can cause widespread and lasting harm well beyond the immediate strike. Applying a broad “dual-use” rationale risks making almost any facility near military activity a target; critics argue that military advantage cannot justify attacks expected to cause excessive civilian harm or that fail to distinguish civilians from combatants.
Explained simply
Mohammad Bagher Ghalibaf is an Iranian politician and negotiator who has held senior roles in Iran’s government. Iran is governed by a system in which elected officials share power with religious institutions and the security forces.
The dispute concerns when civilian facilities can be treated as military targets. Dams, ports and power plants serve the public, but may also support military activity; international rules on armed conflict restrict attacks on civilian objects, with limited exceptions when they are used for military purposes.
The issue matters because damage to essential infrastructure can affect water, electricity and transport for large numbers of people. The United States, Israel and Iran are involved in a wider regional conflict, and claims about military use of civilian sites can shape how attacks are judged.