Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Is that food really made with 100% avocado oil? Likely not
A new study led by food scientist Selina Wang at UC Davis has found that the vast majority of packaged foods labelled as containing pure avocado oil are likely adulterated with cheaper substitutes, undermining a product often marketed as a premium, healthier alternative to seed oils. The findings matter because consumers are paying a premium for a product many are not actually receiving, and because they extend a pattern of fraud Wang's team has documented in avocado oil since 2020.
Researchers chemically analysed 54 products labelled as pure avocado oil alongside 20 olive oil products for comparison. They found 89% of the avocado oil products showed signs of adulteration, mostly with cheaper soybean oil, with one sample containing almost no avocado oil at all; by contrast, only one of the 20 olive oil products appeared adulterated. Price offered no guarantee of authenticity, and most of the avocado oil products cost more than equivalent olive oils despite the substitution. Nutrition experts, including Harvard's Teresa Fung and King's College London's Sarah Berry, questioned avocado oil's "health halo," while the Avocado Oil Manufacturers Association acknowledged the issue and pledged to work on industry-wide standards.
In short
- UC Davis study: 89% of tested "pure" avocado oil products were adulterated
- Cheaper soybean oil was the main substitute found
- Olive oil samples were far less affected; only 1 of 20 adulterated
Explained simply
Avocado oil is a cooking oil pressed from avocados, often marketed as a premium, health-conscious alternative to cheaper seed oils. Many consumers pay significantly more for avocado oil because it is promoted as offering health benefits—though the actual scientific evidence for these claims is contested. The appeal of avocado oil lies in this perception of being a healthier, more natural product than conventional oils.
Food fraud, where manufacturers substitute cheaper ingredients into products whilst falsely labelling them as premium items, has been documented across the food industry for years. Avocado oil is particularly vulnerable to such fraud because cheaper oils like soybean oil can be blended in without obvious visual or taste differences, whilst still commanding high prices on supermarket shelves. This creates strong financial incentive for dishonest producers, and makes fraud difficult to detect without laboratory testing.
Consumers who buy avocado oil are often making a deliberate choice to spend more money based on the product's claimed composition and perceived health benefits. If the product does not contain what the label says, they are not receiving what they paid for, raising questions about food labelling accuracy. This issue extends to broader concerns about trust in food labelling and the role of regulatory systems in preventing such fraud.
Culture Food Politics Research Science