Technology news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘It’s Been a Sh*tshow’ — Esports Casters Call for Change After Embark Studios Replaces Talent for The Finals’ Grand Major Qualifier Highlight Reel With Game’s AI Commentators
Embark Studios faced criticism after an official highlight video for The Finals’ APAC Closed Qualifiers used AI-generated commentary from the game’s fictional characters, Scotty and June, instead of the human casters who had called the matches. Casters and others in esports said the choice sidelined their work, with some also objecting that the AI commentary appeared to draw on their phrasing.
The video was removed after Embark said it had chosen the characters to introduce the tournament to more players, but acknowledged that excluding the broadcast talent was the wrong decision. The studio said it would not release planned recaps in the same format for the AMER and EMEA qualifiers. The characters’ voices were performed by paid human actors, while their match-specific lines use text-to-speech and an AI model trained on those actors’ voices.
In short
- Embark replaced match casters with AI characters in a qualifier recap.
- Casters criticised the decision and the use of their phrasing.
- The video was removed and two planned recaps were cancelled.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Using the game’s familiar characters could make the tournament more accessible to players who do not follow esports, while giving the recap a distinctive style tied to The Finals. The voices were performed by paid actors, and Embark removed the video, acknowledged its mistake and cancelled recaps in the same format, suggesting it took the criticism seriously.
The case against
The human casters supplied the expertise and live commentary that made the matches compelling, so replacing them in the official highlights could make their work seem disposable and deny them visibility. If the AI lines drew on their phrasing, that raises further concerns about using their creative contributions without adequate credit or consent, even if the characters’ voices were based on paid actors.
Explained simply
The Finals is a team-based video game, and esports tournaments let professional players compete in organised matches that are broadcast to viewers. Casters are the commentators who explain the action and add analysis during those broadcasts; Scotty and June are fictional characters in the game.
Embark Studios, which makes The Finals, uses paid actors to perform the characters’ voices. For match-specific commentary, it uses text-to-speech and an AI model trained on those actors’ voices, so the characters can deliver lines about tournament play.
The dispute touches on how esports broadcasts credit and involve the people who commentate them, and how AI-generated voices are used. It also raises questions about whether such voices should reproduce language associated with human commentators.
AI Entertainment Gaming Software Technology