World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Jennifer Sey fights Colorado law that could punish businesses for refusing transgender pronouns
Jennifer Sey, founder of sportswear company XX-XY Athletics, is challenging a Colorado law that she and her lawyers say could penalise businesses for using language about transgender people that conflicts with their beliefs. The case matters because it concerns how far anti-discrimination rules can regulate business speech, and whether a company can seek legal protection before a complaint is made.
The 2025 Kelly Loving Act expanded protections to cover people’s chosen names and forms of address. An attorney for the company says violations can bring fines of up to $3,500, while some advertising violations carry a possible 120-day jail sentence; Colorado has not taken enforcement action against the company. Sey’s company, founded in 2024, campaigns around women’s sports, and she also helped promote Proposition 134, approved by about 52% of Colorado voters and due to take effect on 1 January.
In short
- Jennifer Sey is challenging Colorado’s expanded anti-discrimination law.
- Her company says it could face penalties over its language about transgender athletes.
- Colorado voters approved a separate sports eligibility measure with about 52% support.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A business should not be compelled by the state to use language that conflicts with its owners’ beliefs, particularly where the speech expresses a viewpoint on a contested issue. Supporters of Sey’s challenge argue that possible penalties, including criminal consequences for some advertising violations, can chill lawful expression even before enforcement occurs, so businesses should be able to seek clarity from the courts in advance.
The case against
Colorado can reasonably require businesses to address people by their chosen names and forms of address as part of protecting them from discrimination and exclusion. Supporters of the law may argue that these rules govern conduct in commercial settings, where businesses serve the public, and that allowing refusals on grounds of belief could undermine equal access and leave transgender people without respectful treatment.
Explained simply
Colorado’s Kelly Loving Act extends anti-discrimination protections to how people are addressed, including their chosen names and forms of address. The law applies to businesses as well as other settings, and its supporters say such protections help prevent discrimination against transgender people.
Jennifer Sey founded XX-XY Athletics, a sportswear company that campaigns around women’s sports. She has also supported Proposition 134, a Colorado ballot measure approved by voters and due to take effect on 1 January. The dispute raises questions about how anti-discrimination laws apply to businesses’ public statements and whether a company can ask a court to rule before anyone has filed a complaint.