World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
John Swinney rejects cuts to Scottish benefits ahead of Milburn review
First Minister John Swinney says Scotland should not lose funding if the UK Government changes benefit support following the Milburn Review. He has called on Prime Minister Andy Burnham to rule out Scotland being left worse off, arguing that any reductions could have major effects on Holyrood’s budget.
The review, led by former UK Health Secretary Alan Milburn, is due to be published on Tuesday. Some proposals would apply across the UK, while decisions on devolved areas such as disability benefits would rest with the Scottish Government. Scottish social security spending is projected to rise from £6.7 billion last year to £7.4 billion this year and £7.9 billion next year, nearing £9 billion by the end of the decade. Swinney also cited a £650 million real-terms reduction in next year’s Scottish budget; Conservative leader Russell Findlay accused him of picking a fight with Westminster to deflect attention from rising benefit costs.
In short
- Swinney opposes Scotland losing funding after the Milburn Review.
- Devolved social security spending is projected to approach £9 billion by decade’s end.
- The review includes UK-wide proposals and areas decided by Holyrood.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Swinney’s case is that changes to UK-wide benefit support could reduce funding available to Scotland or create knock-on costs for its devolved budget, so the UK Government should guarantee Scotland is not left worse off. With Scottish social security spending rising sharply and the budget under pressure, clarity before reforms take effect would help Holyrood plan and protect people who depend on support.
The case against
Findlay’s case is that rising benefit costs place a growing strain on public finances, and Swinney should explain how Scotland will manage that pressure rather than focus on a possible dispute with Westminster. On this view, challenging the UK Government over future funding risks diverting attention from difficult choices about the affordability and design of Scotland’s own support.
Explained simply
Scotland has its own government, led by First Minister John Swinney, and it decides how some benefits are run. The UK Government sets other parts of the welfare system, so changes to support can involve both governments.
Alan Milburn, a former UK health secretary, is leading a review of benefit support. Its proposals may affect UK-wide rules, while Scotland retains responsibility for devolved areas such as disability benefits.
Benefit payments are funded from public budgets, and Scotland’s social security spending is forecast to rise over the next few years. Any UK-wide changes could therefore affect Scotland’s finances, while decisions on devolved benefits would be made by the Scottish Government.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by Daily Mail as “John Swinney under fire for opposing any efforts to cut spending on benefits before a new review is even published”.