Culture news and discussion on TalkFuse.
JONATHAN BROCKLEBANK: Why HAS the SNP allowed our priceless heritage to burn to the ground?
Columnist Jonathan Brocklebank criticises the Scottish Government for allowing the fire-damaged Glasgow School of Art, designed by Charles Rennie Mackintosh, to remain a derelict shell for more than eight years while the city celebrates a new public artwork honouring the same architect. He contrasts this with the response to the 2019 Notre Dame fire in Paris, where President Emmanuel Macron pledged immediate reconstruction and the cathedral was fully restored within roughly five and a half years, arguing that Scotland's leadership showed no comparable urgency or ambition after the Glasgow building burned.
The Mackintosh-designed art school, completed in 1909 and regarded by many architects as "Scotland's Notre Dame," was gutted by fires in both 2014 and 2018. A full restoration has now been costed at £265million, deemed unaffordable, meaning only a partial rebuild will proceed, with scaffolding removed and the façade retained rather than the interior fully reinstated. The piece notes this plan was welcomed as a "milestone" by Historic Environment Scotland's chief executive, Katerina Brown, a characterisation the author disputes, framing it instead as a resigned acceptance of national heritage loss.
In short
- Glasgow School of Art remains a burnt-out shell eight years after fires
- Full £265million restoration deemed unaffordable; only façade to be kept
- Author contrasts inaction with France's swift Notre Dame rebuild
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The Glasgow School of Art represents Scotland's most significant architectural contribution to world design, created by Charles Rennie Mackintosh at the pinnacle of his career. When a nation's priceless cultural heritage is damaged, restoration ought to be prioritised as a matter of national duty and pride, signalling to future generations that the country values its artistic legacy. The French example demonstrates that when political will exists, even extraordinary restoration is achievable, suggesting that Scotland's eight-year delay reflects insufficient ambition and urgency from its leadership rather than genuine fiscal impossibility.
The case against
Allocating £265 million from constrained public budgets significantly affects resources for healthcare, education, and social services serving millions of Scots. A partial rebuild that preserves the building's shell and returns it to functional use represents responsible stewardship of public resources whilst still honouring the heritage. The Notre Dame comparison, though rhetorically appealing, overlooks that the cathedral has international significance and received substantial international funding under distinct political circumstances. A pragmatic approach acknowledging competing priorities reflects sound governance, and preserving the building's façade and enabling its use constitutes meaningful heritage protection rather than failure.
Explained simply
The Glasgow School of Art was designed by Scottish architect Charles Rennie Mackintosh and completed in 1909. It is widely regarded as one of his most important buildings and a landmark of Scottish architecture.
Two fires, in 2014 and 2018, badly damaged the school. A full restoration has been estimated at £265 million, and the current plan is for a partial rebuild that keeps the façade but does not fully restore the interior.
The debate involves the school, the Scottish Government and heritage bodies such as Historic Environment Scotland, which has described the plan as a milestone. It raises questions about how the cost of restoring historic buildings is weighed against their cultural value and who should fund that work.