New releases, music videos and album news — indie, rap, rock and pop. Always covering Ren, Chris Webby, Sam Tompkins, bbno$, CHINCHILLA, Muse, Yungblud and more.
Journey’s Jonathan Cain says Bruce Springsteen is “an annoying, bitter old man” who “should shut up” about politics
Journey keyboardist Jonathan Cain has criticised Bruce Springsteen, calling him "an annoying, bitter old man" and suggesting he "should shut up" about politics. The comments, made on The Complete Disaster Network podcast, come amid ongoing tension between musicians who mix political commentary with their art and those, like Cain, who prefer to keep the two separate.
Cain, who is releasing a patriotic song titled 'The Winds Of Freedom: A Salute To America' for the country's 250th anniversary, said he tries to keep politics out of his music and criticised celebrities including Robert De Niro for speaking out politically. He also took aim at Springsteen's 'Born In The USA', calling it "a diss to our country", and named himself and Kid Rock as rare conservative voices in music. The remarks follow Springsteen's recent PBS special in which he championed "critical patriotism" and discussed his new protest song 'Streets Of Minneapolis', written in response to an ICE incident in Minneapolis.
In short
- Jonathan Cain calls Bruce Springsteen "annoying" for discussing politics
- Cain says he keeps politics out of his own music
- Comments follow Springsteen's PBS special on "critical patriotism"
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Artists have a responsibility to unite rather than divide their audiences, and music serves better as a transcendent, universal medium when it remains apolitical. Injecting partisan messaging alienates listeners and transforms entertainment into propaganda, forcing people to choose between enjoying art and maintaining their own views. Many music fans seek escape and joy from art rather than political lectures, and artists wield considerable cultural influence—a power better used to entertain and inspire broadly than to advance specific political agendas.
The case against
Artists are citizens with equal right to political expression, and music has always been inherently political, from protest songs to civil rights anthems. Refusing to engage with injustice amounts to complicity rather than neutrality, whilst critical patriotism—holding one's country accountable—represents genuine love of country. The demand that artists remain silent on social issues silences dissent and protects the status quo, and great art has always grappled with injustice and human suffering.
Explained simply
Bruce Springsteen and Jonathan Cain are both prominent rock musicians with long careers. Springsteen, known for albums such as "Born in the USA", has made political commentary a consistent part of his work and public identity. Cain is the keyboardist for the band Journey and has pursued a different strategy, keeping his music and politics largely separate throughout his career.
There is a long-running cultural conversation about whether musicians should use their platforms for political discussion. Some argue that artists have a responsibility to speak out on important social and political issues, whilst others believe that entertainment and politics should remain distinct. This debate has become more prominent in recent years.
Springsteen has recently discussed his philosophy of "critical patriotism" and released new music addressing political subjects. Cain has been working on patriotic music and has become increasingly vocal about his view that celebrities should keep entertainment separate from political commentary. Their disagreement reflects deeper divisions within the music world over the role artists should play in public discourse.