Video games news, releases, esports and culture — all the biggest gaming stories in one place.
Judge Denies Motion to Dismiss RAM Price Fixing Lawsuit
A judge has refused to dismiss a class action accusing Micron, SK Hynix and Samsung of conspiring to raise RAM prices while reducing production. The decision allows the lawsuit to proceed, but it does not establish that the companies colluded or mean that prices will fall.
The complaint alleges that conventional DRAM prices rose 697% over 18 months, compared with a 165% increase cited in connection with a 2018 case that was dismissed. The companies argued they acted independently and that the lawsuit repeated claims from that earlier case; Judge Noël Wise said the allegations described companies acting “in formation”. A 2002 US investigation into the same manufacturers resulted in a Samsung executive receiving jail time, and fines of $300 million for Samsung and $185 million for SK Hynix. The current case may take years, while manufacturers have said AI demand is likely to tighten supply further.
In short
- The RAM price-fixing case against three manufacturers can proceed.
- The complaint alleges conventional DRAM prices rose 697% in 18 months.
- The ruling does not prove collusion or promise lower prices.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The lawsuit should proceed because the complaint describes unusually large price rises alongside reduced production and alleges coordinated conduct among firms that dominate the DRAM market. Letting the case examine evidence could help determine whether consumers were harmed and whether competition rules were broken, especially given a past price-fixing case involving the same manufacturers.
The case against
A judge’s decision to let the case proceed is not a finding that the companies colluded, and the firms say they set prices independently. The allegations resemble claims dismissed in an earlier case, while strong demand from AI and other uses could explain tighter supply and higher prices; requiring years of litigation without proof could impose substantial costs on the companies.
Explained simply
RAM is short-term memory that computers use while running programmes. DRAM is a common type, made by a small number of major manufacturers, including Micron, SK Hynix and Samsung. Because these firms supply much of the market, changes in production can affect prices for computer makers and consumers.
The lawsuit alleges that the companies coordinated their decisions to limit production and raise prices. The firms say they acted independently. A separate US case in the early 2000s led to criminal penalties for Samsung and SK Hynix, but that history does not determine the outcome of the current claims.
The dispute matters because RAM is used in computers, phones and data centres, and its cost can affect the price of those products. Demand from artificial intelligence services is also putting pressure on memory supplies, making the market’s direction important to manufacturers and buyers.