Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Labour MPs quit Somaliland group over Israel and chair’s ties to far-right Restore
Labour MPs Kim Johnson and Abtisam Mohamed have left the all-party parliamentary group on Somaliland, while Kerry McCarthy has stopped taking part. Their actions follow concerns about the group’s engagement with Israel and its chair, Conservative MP Gavin Williamson, who has links to the anti-immigration party Restore Britain. The departures have disrupted Westminster’s main parliamentary forum focused on Somaliland and its diaspora.
Johnson said she left a May event marking Somaliland’s self-declared independence after learning an Israeli government official was attending; she later resigned from the group. Mohamed, her deputy, resigned this week, and McCarthy says she will not participate until Williamson steps down. The group has not met since before Parliament’s summer recess, amid controversy over Israel’s recognition of Somaliland and Williamson’s ties to Restore Britain.
In short
- Three Labour MPs have withdrawn from the Somaliland group.
- An Israeli official’s attendance prompted Kim Johnson to leave an event.
- The group has not met since before Parliament’s summer recess.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The departures can be defended as a matter of political principle and trust: MPs may reasonably object to an event involving an Israeli government official, particularly amid controversy over Israel’s recognition of Somaliland, and may judge that the chair’s links to Restore Britain undermine confidence in the group. Stepping away or withholding participation can signal that parliamentary forums should reflect their members’ standards and avoid lending legitimacy to positions they oppose.
The case against
The group provides a parliamentary forum for discussion of Somaliland and its diaspora, so MPs could argue that leaving weakens scrutiny and representation without changing the chair’s conduct or the group’s direction. They may also regard engagement with an Israeli official as relevant diplomacy rather than endorsement, and prefer to challenge Williamson’s leadership or the group’s activities from within.
Explained simply
Somaliland is a territory in the Horn of Africa that declared independence from Somalia in 1991, but it is not widely recognised as a country. It has its own government and institutions, and people from Somaliland living abroad form a sizeable diaspora.
All-party parliamentary groups bring MPs and peers from different parties together to discuss a particular subject; they are informal and are not government bodies. The Somaliland group provides a Westminster forum for discussing the territory and its diaspora. Israel’s recognition of Somaliland has become a point of dispute, while the group’s chair, Conservative MP Gavin Williamson, has links to Restore Britain, a party focused on immigration.
Government Middle East Politics UK World