Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Labour’s national insurance hike fuelled youth unemployment crisis, Milburn warns
Alan Milburn says Labour’s National Insurance increases have made it harder for companies to hire young people and contributed to pressure in the youth labour market. The former cabinet minister argues the government needs a “course correction” as it tackles long-running joblessness among under-25s.
His report addresses around one million young people not in education, employment or training, proposing changes to benefits, new apprenticeships and a £3,000 employer incentive. It also recommends a new youth allowance that would replace some support currently available through Personal Independence Payment and Universal Credit, a change Milburn says could leave some people with less financial help.
In short
- Milburn says National Insurance rises made youth hiring harder.
- His report targets about one million young people outside education or work.
- Proposals include apprenticeships, employer payments and benefit changes.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Milburn’s warning argue that higher National Insurance raises the cost of employing people, making firms more cautious about hiring young workers who often need more training and support. With youth joblessness already persistent, they say a targeted employer incentive and stronger routes into apprenticeships could help more young people get a foothold in work.
The case against
Critics could argue that National Insurance is only one factor in youth unemployment, alongside weak demand, skills gaps and longstanding barriers to work, so attributing the crisis to the rise risks overstating its effect. They may also question whether employer subsidies and changes to benefits will create lasting, secure jobs, particularly if a new youth allowance leaves some disabled or otherwise vulnerable young people with less support.
Explained simply
National Insurance is a payroll tax paid by workers and employers in the UK. When the amount employers pay rises, hiring can become more expensive, though its effect on recruitment can vary between businesses and sectors.
Alan Milburn is a former Labour cabinet minister asked to examine employment among young people. The term “NEET” describes people under 25 who are not in education, employment or training; the figure cited in the report is about one million.
The debate matters because long spells without work or study can affect young people’s income and future job prospects. The proposals touch on both help into work, such as apprenticeships and employer incentives, and benefits including Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment.
Business Economy Government Politics