World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Letby lawyer seeks urgent appeal review after prosecution expert concerns emerge
Lucy Letby’s lawyer has called for the Court of Appeal to urgently review her convictions after reports that a key prosecution expert had been barred from treating patients over safety concerns. The development raises questions about why information about the expert was not disclosed to the defence, and whether it could have affected the trial.
Professor Peter Hindmarsh gave evidence that two babies had been poisoned with insulin, forming a crucial part of the case in which Letby was convicted of attempting to murder them. UCLH excluded him from clinical practice in March 2023 and raised concerns with the General Medical Council, including cases in which he had advised children to stop taking insulin; the jury, Letby’s defence and the CPS were not told. Letby was convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others, and is serving 15 whole-life terms; previous appeal applications were rejected, while her lawyer has applied to the Criminal Cases Review Commission for a referral back to the Court of Appeal.
In short
- Letby’s lawyer wants her convictions urgently reviewed.
- A key insulin expert was barred from clinical practice.
- The defence and jury were not told of the restriction.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The reported concerns about Professor Hindmarsh’s clinical practice and the failure to disclose them to the defence raise a serious question about whether the jury had information needed to assess a key expert witness. An urgent review could establish whether the undisclosed material was relevant to his insulin evidence and whether it might have affected the convictions, while upholding the principle that a fair trial requires meaningful disclosure.
The case against
The reported concerns arose from clinical practice and do not, by themselves, show that Professor Hindmarsh’s evidence about the babies was wrong or that the trial was unfair. The convictions followed a jury trial and earlier appeal applications were rejected; any further review should therefore assess the material’s relevance carefully, without treating an expert’s separate professional difficulties as proof that the verdicts cannot stand.
Explained simply
Lucy Letby is a former neonatal nurse convicted of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others at the Countess of Chester Hospital. She is serving 15 whole-life sentences, and earlier attempts to appeal her convictions were rejected.
A key part of the case concerned two babies whose insulin levels were said to show they had been poisoned. Professor Peter Hindmarsh gave evidence for the prosecution on that issue. Reports say his hospital, University College London Hospitals, had barred him from clinical work over safety concerns and referred concerns about his practice to the medical regulator.
The defence, jury and prosecution service were not told about those concerns during the trial. Letby’s lawyer has asked the Criminal Cases Review Commission to refer the case back to the Court of Appeal, which could consider whether the undisclosed information has a bearing on the convictions.
Read the full article at the source →
Originally published by The Guardian as “Lawyer calls for urgent review of Letby convictions after expert witness revelations”.