World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Lawyer who was fired after taking a sickie to attend the footy ordered to pay back thousands to his old bosses
A solicitor has been ordered to pay his former employer $22,500 after the Fair Work Commission found that his conduct during an unfair dismissal case caused unreasonable costs. Mitchell Fuller had been dismissed by Melbourne firm Madison Branson Lawyers after saying he was unwell while attending AFL Gather Round in Adelaide; his unfair dismissal claim was rejected.
The commission said Fuller made false statements to his employer and gave false evidence. The firm’s internal review began in July 2024, after a human resources consultant found social media photos linking him to the football weekend. In its latest decision, the commission said Fuller submitted fictional or irrelevant legal authorities, apparently generated with artificial intelligence, and failed to check them.
In short
- Mitchell Fuller must repay his former law firm $22,500.
- The order concerns costs from his failed unfair dismissal case.
- The commission criticised his use of unchecked AI-generated legal authorities.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The commission’s order can be defended as a way to protect the fairness and integrity of workplace proceedings: knowingly false statements and unchecked, irrelevant authorities can impose avoidable costs on an employer and undermine confidence in the process. Requiring Fuller to repay some of those costs may reinforce that parties must take care and act honestly when bringing claims.
The case against
A costs order of $22,500 may be seen as a serious penalty for someone pursuing an employment claim, especially if it risks discouraging workers from challenging dismissals. Even where a claim fails and conduct is criticised, costs rules should be applied carefully and proportionately so that access to workplace justice is not chilled.
Explained simply
The Fair Work Commission is Australia’s workplace tribunal, which deals with disputes between employers and workers. An employee who believes they were unfairly dismissed can ask it to review their case, and it can also consider who should cover costs caused by the case.
Mitchell Fuller was a solicitor at Madison Branson Lawyers, a Melbourne law firm. His employer investigated after social media photos appeared to show him at an Australian Football League weekend in Adelaide when he had said he was unwell.
The dispute matters because it concerns both the limits of unfair dismissal claims and the duty to give truthful evidence in legal proceedings. The commission also considered whether legal material apparently produced using artificial intelligence had been checked before it was submitted.