World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Lazy parents who send their kids to school in nappies are failing them in the worst possible way
The opinion article argues that many children starting primary school lack basic skills such as using the toilet, eating independently and speaking, and places responsibility chiefly on parents. It says this can leave pupils behind from the outset and may affect their later education and employment prospects.
The article cites an Alan Milburn report on youth worklessness and says teachers report nearly 60 per cent of five-year-olds are not “school ready”. It also claims one in four start school in nappies, while similar proportions cannot manage basic self-care; 28 per cent, it says, have never been taught to talk. These figures and claims are presented in an opinion piece that excludes children with special needs from its criticism.
In short
- The article blames parents for children starting school without basic skills.
- It cites teachers’ estimate that nearly 60% of five-year-olds are not school ready.
- It argues early gaps may affect children’s future learning and work.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Children benefit when they arrive at school able to communicate basic needs and manage everyday tasks such as eating and using the toilet. Parents have a central role in building these skills, and where they are not taught, teachers may have less time to support learning and pupils may find the transition harder. Early preparation could therefore help children settle in and make the most of their education.
The case against
School readiness varies, and difficulties with self-care or speech may reflect a child’s development, health, circumstances or access to support rather than parental neglect. Schools and public services also share responsibility for identifying needs and helping families, especially where pressures or limited resources make early support harder to obtain. Claims about later educational or employment outcomes should be treated cautiously unless the evidence establishes a clear link.
Explained simply
Children in England usually start Reception in the September after they turn four, with the first year of primary school beginning the move from early years settings into more structured learning. Schools and families may use “school ready” to describe skills that help children take part, such as communicating, eating and managing the toilet, though children develop at different rates.
Responsibility for helping children build these skills is shared between families, early years providers and schools. Children may need extra support because of disability, developmental differences or other circumstances, so readiness figures depend on how they are defined and measured. The debate matters because early difficulties can affect a child’s experience of school, while claims about later education or employment are broader and cannot be attributed to one factor alone.