Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Leaked texts show how Liberals knifed Nationals for Pauline Hanson’s One Nation in explosive revelation set to spark a political civil war ahead of Victoria election: PVO
Leaked messages reportedly show senior Victorian Liberals trying to help their candidate, Megan Read, or One Nation’s Donna Buxton defeat Nationals candidate Jo Armstrong in the marginal seat of Ripon. The revelations raise questions about the Coalition’s public claim that its parties are united ahead of the Victorian election, and could strain trust between them.
In the messages, a Liberal official said they were working to elect Read or Buxton, adding “not bloody Jo”, while a Liberal MP urged One Nation not to place Armstrong ahead of Read on its how-to-vote card. Labor’s Martha Haylett holds Ripon by 3 per cent, and the article says the seat is unlikely to remain with Labor. Opposition leader Jess Wilson has ruled out a deal with One Nation to form government in a hung parliament, while acknowledging the Coalition would generally preference it ahead of Labor.
In short
- Leaked texts suggest Liberals backed Read or One Nation over Nationals candidate Armstrong.
- Ripon is a marginal seat held by Labor on a 3 per cent margin.
- The revelations may test trust within the Coalition before the Victorian election.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A Liberal advocate could argue that the messages reflect a tactical effort to defeat Labor in a seat the article says is likely to change hands, and that encouraging One Nation voters to favour the Liberal candidate is ordinary electoral campaigning. They might also say that preference decisions are part of the parties’ public strategy and do not, by themselves, amount to a formal agreement with One Nation.
The case against
A Nationals advocate could argue that urging support for One Nation over the Nationals candidate in a marginal seat breaches the trust and mutual support expected within the Coalition, especially while its parties publicly claim unity. Even without a formal deal, the messages could weaken the Nationals’ electoral prospects and raise doubts about whether Liberal assurances of partnership can be relied upon.
Explained simply
Victoria’s Liberal Party and Nationals are separate parties that usually work together as the Coalition. They share an opposition to Labor, but compete for votes in some country seats, including Ripon, where Labor’s Martha Haylett won by a 3 per cent margin.
In Ripon, Liberal candidate Megan Read and Nationals candidate Jo Armstrong are both seeking votes, alongside One Nation candidate Donna Buxton. How-to-vote cards suggest an order for ranking candidates, though voters can choose their own preferences; where a candidate places others can affect their chances as votes are redistributed.
The reported messages raise questions about trust between the Liberals and Nationals as they campaign together. The parties’ relationship matters to their prospects of challenging Labor, while One Nation’s role is also relevant to debate about preference flows and possible arrangements in a closely divided parliament.