World news and discussion on TalkFuse.
‘Lord of Fraud’ conman, 79, who spent years behind bars after plotting world’s biggest bank raid avoids more jail time despite being caught with hundreds of child sex abuse images
Hugh Rodley, 79, has received a suspended sentence after admitting six counts of making indecent images of children and one count of possessing them. The case has drawn attention because police found hundreds of images and extensive searches for child sexual abuse material, while Rodley had previously served prison sentences for major frauds.
The images were found on a laptop and a phone: police recorded 198 on the laptop, including 19 in the most serious category, and 295 on the phone, including five in that category. The court imposed 12 months for each offence, to run concurrently, suspended for 18 months, with probation, an £85 costs order and a £187 surcharge; Rodley was also placed on the sex offenders register for ten years and made subject to a Sexual Harm Prevention Order. His past convictions include an eight-year sentence in 2009 over a failed attempt to steal £229 million from a Japanese bank.
In short
- Hugh Rodley’s prison sentence for image offences was suspended for 18 months.
- Police found 493 images across his laptop and phone.
- He was placed on the sex offenders register for ten years.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A suspended sentence can be defended as a proportionate response if the court judged that the offences, the defendant’s age and circumstances, and the available evidence of future risk did not require immediate imprisonment. Probation, a ten-year sex offenders register requirement and a Sexual Harm Prevention Order impose supervision and restrictions, while suspension gives a clear consequence if he reoffends.
The case against
Immediate imprisonment can be argued to be necessary given the hundreds of images, including material in the most serious category, and the extensive searches reported. A custodial sentence could better reflect the harm represented by child sexual abuse material, provide stronger punishment and deterrence, and reassure the public that serious offending is treated consistently, regardless of age or past notoriety.
Explained simply
Hugh Rodley is a convicted fraudster who was jailed in 2009 for his part in a failed attempt to steal £229 million from a Japanese bank. The plan involved a group seeking to obtain control of the bank’s funds; it was described at the time as an attempted major bank robbery.
The current case concerns child sexual abuse material found on Rodley’s laptop and phone. British law distinguishes between levels of such images according to their severity, and offences can include making or possessing them. His earlier fraud convictions form part of the background to public interest in the case, but are separate from the offences involving the images.