Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
LSU adds ex-St. John’s star RJ Luis Jr. to roster as eligibility drama takes another turn
LSU has added former St John’s star RJ Luis Jr to its roster after a judge’s order blocked the NCAA from treating him as ineligible. The move is the latest development in a months-long dispute over whether his professional basketball contracts prevent him from playing college basketball.
Luis committed to LSU in May but signed a two-way deal with the Utah Jazz and an Exhibit 10 contract with the Boston Celtics before the 2025-26 season; he played in three NBA pre-season games but no regular-season or G League games. He averaged 18.2 points and 7.2 rebounds in his final St John’s season and was named Big East Player of the Year. LSU says the court ruling made him eligible under the SEC rules then in force, while the SEC has since adopted a tougher interpretation; it is unclear whether he will play against Louisiana Monroe.
In short
- LSU has put RJ Luis Jr on its roster following a court order.
- His eligibility remains disputed after a change in SEC interpretation.
- The former Big East Player of the Year averaged 18.2 points at St John’s.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Luis’s supporters can argue that he should be allowed to play because he appeared only in NBA pre-season games and never in a regular-season or G League game, despite signing contracts. His college record and commitment to LSU also support treating his case on its particular facts, especially while a judge’s order prevents the NCAA from declaring him ineligible under the rules at issue.
The case against
Those favouring a stricter eligibility line can argue that signing NBA contracts is a meaningful step into professional basketball, regardless of whether Luis went on to play regular-season or G League games. Consistent rules can protect fairness among college teams and preserve a clear distinction between college athletes and players who have entered the professional system; the SEC’s tougher interpretation reflects that concern.
Explained simply
College athletes in the United States are generally subject to NCAA rules on eligibility, including limits on playing professionally before or during college. The NCAA governs many college sports, while conferences such as the SEC and Big East set rules for groups of universities and organise competition.
RJ Luis Jr is a basketball player who earned Big East Player of the Year honours at St John’s before pursuing opportunities with NBA teams. His contracts and pre-season appearances raised questions about whether he could return to college basketball, even though he did not play in a regular-season or G League game.
The dispute matters because it tests how professional contracts affect a player’s college eligibility, and how those rules are applied by the NCAA, conferences and courts. Different interpretations can affect both a player’s options and the teams competing in college basketball.