Manchester City’s glory cannot be taken away from the players, says Kyle Walker
Former Manchester City captain Kyle Walker says the club’s glory years and the players’ memories of their trophies cannot be taken away, despite an independent commission finding City guilty of breaching Premier League financial rules. The verdict covers a nine-year period, and City have appealed.
Walker, now Burnley’s captain, said the finding “doesn’t look great” but declined to comment on the legal proceedings while the appeal is under way. He spent eight years at City, from 2017 to 2025, winning the Champions League and 12 major domestic honours. City say the ruling contains material errors and that the club is innocent.
- Walker says City’s trophies remain part of the players’ memories.
- City were found guilty of financial rule breaches over nine years.
- The club has appealed the commission’s judgment.
New here? Start with this
Manchester City has been found guilty of breaching Premier League financial regulations by an independent commission. The Premier League enforces rules limiting how much clubs can spend on wages and transfers, designed to keep spending under control and ensure that all clubs operate financially responsibly.
The investigation examined Manchester City's accounts over a nine-year period, during which the club won the Premier League title multiple times, the FA Cup, and the Champions League. Manchester City became one of the world's most successful football clubs during these years, dominating English football under manager Pep Guardiola. The club has disputed the commission's findings and is appealing the decision.
The outcome remains uncertain while the appeal is under way. The case has prompted wider discussion about how financial regulations work in professional football and their relationship to sporting success.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The sporting achievements of players on the pitch are genuine and cannot be erased by off-field financial matters, especially whilst the club's appeal remains ongoing and the findings are disputed. The glory belongs to the players who performed fairly and competed fairly in competition, regardless of how club administration and finances were managed behind the scenes.
The case against
If Manchester City's financial breaches provided unfair competitive advantages over nine years—enabling superior player recruitment, wages, and facilities than permitted—then sporting achievements built on that tainted foundation are fundamentally compromised. Accepting this is essential to maintaining the integrity and competitive fairness that professional sport requires.