Maren Morris, Flavor Flav, Maggie Baird & More Speak Out Against Shane Gillis ‘SNL’ Monologue: ‘It’s Actually Dangerous for Women’
Comedian Shane Gillis drew significant backlash for a joke in his Saturday Night Live monologue that referred to women wearing short gym shorts as "whores." Multiple celebrities, including actor Dan Levy and musician Maren Morris, publicly criticised the remark on social media, with some arguing it was misogynistic and reinforced harmful stereotypes. The controversy reignited broader discussion about comedy boundaries and whether such material remains acceptable in the current cultural moment.
Dan Levy's Instagram video response became the focal point, with his comments section flooded by support from stars including Jewel, Kristin Chenoweth and Lisa Loeb. Maggie Baird, mother of Billie Eilish and FINNEAS, shared the video and called the joke "actually dangerous for women," comparing it to a controversial 2020 Bill Burr monologue. Flavour Flav also voiced support for the criticism. This marked Gillis's third time hosting SNL; he was previously removed from becoming a cast member in 2019 when earlier homophobic and racist jokes resurfaced.
- Shane Gillis criticised for calling women in gym shorts whores on SNL
- Multiple celebrities including Dan Levy called it misogynistic
- Gillis previously dismissed from SNL over offensive jokes
New here? Start with this
Shane Gillis is a stand-up comedian who has appeared on Saturday Night Live multiple times. During a recent episode, he made a joke in his monologue that referred to women wearing short gym shorts as "whores." The remark prompted criticism from celebrities who found it insulting and offensive.
Several notable figures, including actor Dan Levy and musician Maren Morris, publicly criticised the joke on social media. Maggie Baird, a musician and mother of Billie Eilish, described the comment as "actually dangerous for women" and compared it to an earlier controversial monologue from 2020. Critics have argued that the joke perpetuates harmful stereotypes about women based on how they dress.
The backlash has reignited wider conversation about acceptable boundaries in comedy and whether crude material targeting women remains appropriate. This controversy comes at a notable moment, as Gillis was previously blocked from becoming an SNL cast member in 2019 after homophobic and racist jokes from his earlier work surfaced.
Both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
The joke reduces women to a dehumanising slur based solely on their clothing choices, reinforcing the harmful logic that blames women for harassment and judgment rather than holding men accountable for their gaze and speech. This framing on a mainstream platform like SNL contributes to a culture where women's bodies are positioned as objects worthy of moral condemnation, a dynamic with real consequences for how women navigate public spaces. Given Gillis's documented history of offensive material since 2019, this represents a pattern rather than an isolated transgression, suggesting a consistent mode of expression that merits scrutiny about its place on major networks.
The case against
Comedy has long thrived on provocative, absurdist exaggeration that deliberately violates social norms—the point is precisely to unsettle rather than to advocate literally. The joke's hyperbolic nature makes clear it is not a serious argument about women's character but rather deliberate provocation designed to create discomfort, which is a legitimate artistic tool. Attributing real-world harm to a comedian's punchline conflates expression with causation in ways that would restrict artistic freedom severely; countless edgy comedians offend audiences without materially changing behaviour, and that gap between speech and action is crucial to distinguish.