Entertainment news and discussion on TalkFuse.
MGM+’s Biggest Horror Hit Is Officially Scaring Away Audiences
MGM+'s acclaimed horror series From is experiencing a significant disconnect between critical and audience reception. Whilst the show has maintained exceptional critical ratings (consistently above 95% on Rotten Tomatoes), viewer scores have declined sharply, suggesting audiences are losing interest despite professional praise. The series remains MGM+'s most popular show overall and still ranks second on its home platform, but it has begun disappearing from international streaming charts.
The ratings gap has widened considerably over the show's run. Season 1 saw critics and audiences relatively aligned (96% vs 87%), but by Season 4, the gap had grown dramatically to 96% critical acclaim against just 64% from viewers. Whilst shows typically experience declining engagement after new seasons air, the steepness of From's audience decline is unusual for such a popular series, suggesting viewers' investment in the storyline and characters has waned despite ongoing critical acclaim.
In short
- Critical ratings remain above 95% whilst audience scores have collapsed to 64%
- Show ranks second on MGM+ but vanishing from international streaming charts
- Growing disconnect indicates viewers losing interest despite critical praise
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Critics’ sustained praise and the show’s continued position as MGM+’s most popular programme suggest that From remains compelling for viewers who value its atmosphere, performances and gradual mysteries. A falling audience score or weaker international chart presence may reflect changing expectations, a narrower remaining audience or normal variation in who rates a season, rather than a broad loss of interest.
The case against
The widening gap between critics’ scores and audience ratings, alongside the show’s retreat from some international charts, supports the view that From is losing part of its audience. The sharper decline by Season 4 may indicate that its story or character development is no longer rewarding viewers who invested in earlier seasons, even as critics continue to value its craft.
Explained simply
From is a horror series shown on MGM+, a streaming service owned by Amazon. It follows people trapped in a strange town, where they try to survive and understand why they cannot leave.
Critics and viewers rate programmes differently: critics assess shows professionally, while viewer scores reflect audience reactions. From has kept very strong critics’ ratings, but its audience scores have fallen over successive seasons.
That gap matters because audience response can affect whether people keep watching and how widely a show is discussed. From remains MGM+’s most popular series, though it has slipped from some international streaming charts.