Politics news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Milburn calls for ‘entirely new’ benefits system to cut £13bn. Here’s what could change
Alan Milburn’s government-backed review proposes an entirely new benefits system for under-25s, aiming to reduce the number who are not in education, employment or training and help more young people into work. It would replace Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment for younger claimants with new arrangements, but could leave some people with less support at the start of a claim.
The report says about one million young people are currently not in education, employment or training, and six in ten have never had a job. It proposes investing £5.8 billion a year in employment schemes over the next decade, alongside £3.6 billion in direct welfare savings and £2.4 billion from higher tax receipts and lower benefit claims; combined welfare cuts would reach £13.7 billion by 2036/37. The proposed Youth Allowance would be means-tested at the basic Universal Credit rate, without health top-ups, while new local support would replace disability benefits for under-25s.
In short
- Milburn proposes a new benefits system for under-25s.
- Universal Credit and PIP would be replaced for younger claimants.
- The report projects £13.7bn in welfare cuts by 2036/37.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
A distinct system for under-25s could address the high number who are not in work or education by combining income support with tailored employment help. Supporters could argue that substantial investment in training and job schemes may improve young people’s prospects over time, while reducing long-term benefit dependence and public costs.
The case against
Replacing existing benefits could leave young people, especially those with health conditions or disabilities, with less reliable support when they need it. Critics could argue that expected savings and higher employment depend on schemes delivering results, while removing health top-ups risks hardship and may make it harder for some people to take part in work or training.
Explained simply
Universal Credit is the main means-tested benefit for people on low incomes or out of work, while Personal Independence Payment helps with some extra costs of disability. The proposals would create different arrangements for people under 25, including a means-tested Youth Allowance and local support in place of disability benefits.
The review focuses on young people who are not in education, work or training; it says about one million are in this position, and six in ten have never had a job. It proposes spending on employment schemes to help more young people move into work.
The plan also aims to reduce benefit spending and raise tax receipts over time. Some young people could receive less support when they first claim, so the changes could affect both access to help and public spending.