Business news and discussion on TalkFuse.
Milburn review risks leaving NEETs in the worst of all worlds
Alan Milburn’s review aims to cut the proportion of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) from 13 per cent to five per cent over ten years. The article argues that the UK’s persistently high rate points to a structural problem, and that the review risks combining useful reforms with more state intervention that may not work.
The review proposes reducing employer National Insurance, easing regulation and slowing minimum-wage increases to lower the cost of hiring young people. It also suggests a new youth allowance for under-25s claiming certain health-related benefits, with a requirement to engage in support, alongside expanded employment programmes and local job guarantees. The author doubts these programmes will prove cost-effective and questions whether Labour MPs and activists will support the benefit changes.
In short
- Around 1 million young people in the UK are NEET.
- Milburn wants to reduce the rate from 13% to 5% in a decade.
- The review pairs welfare reforms with expanded employment support.
Steelman: both sides, in good faith
The strongest fair case each way — we don't pick a winner.
The case for
Supporters of Milburn’s review can argue that persistently high youth inactivity reflects structural barriers that require a coordinated response, not simply a stronger jobs market. Lower hiring costs and lighter regulation could encourage employers to take a chance on young people, while targeted support, engagement requirements and local job guarantees could help those facing health or other obstacles move towards work or training.
The case against
Critics can argue that the review combines sensible steps to make hiring easier with costly programmes and greater state direction whose results are uncertain. They may question whether employment schemes and job guarantees offer value for money, and warn that slower minimum-wage rises could weaken young workers’ pay; benefit conditions may also prove politically difficult and risk adding pressure without creating suitable jobs.
Explained simply
NEET describes young people who are not in education, employment or training. The term covers people in different circumstances, including those looking for work and those unable to work because of health problems, so the overall rate can reflect several issues.
Alan Milburn has been asked to review how to reduce the number of young people in this position. His proposals include changing the costs and rules employers face when hiring, offering more employment support, and linking a new allowance for some under-25s on health-related benefits to taking part in support.
The debate is about how far government should go in helping young people into work, and how to balance that support with the costs and conditions attached to it. The choices could affect young people, employers and public spending.